Spiller vs B. Tate @ 1.4

[KU Sucks]

Who would you take and why?

PPR, standard scoring except punt & kickoff tds count.

B. Roethlisberger
J. Flacco
T. Edwards - x
R. Grant
R. Mendenhall
J. Charles
J. Stewart
J. Davis
B. Scott
M. Colston
M. Austin
P. Harvin
G. Camarillo - x
B. Berrian - x
B. Robiskie - x
J. Shockey
G. Olsen
F. Davis
K.Brown - x
Jets
49ers
open roster spot

1.4, 2.2, 2.4, 3.4 & 5.4 (if I want it)

[Steelersfan]

I think you have to go Spiller here. I like Tates situation more but Spiller is far more talented IMO.

[Orca]

Spiller long term

Tate if you want immediate production...

but yeah, Spiller is who I would take.

[BeRanDone]

Spiller since it's PPR.

Hell, even Spiller if it wasn't PPR. He's just a better talent that will overcome his situation sooner or later.

[skip]

Spiller on the board at 1.4 is a gift.

[KU Sucks]

I actually don't need rb production right away. I have Mendy, Grant, Charles, & J. Stew; and can only start 2. So I can afford to wait a year.

I tried to trade down a couple of spots, but no serious offers. At spot #4 your looking at Spiller and Tate in this league. Should one of the other top 3 fall instead of Spiller, then IMO it isn't an issue.

[meineymoe]

I actually don't need rb production right away. I have Mendy, Grant, Charles, & J. Stew; and can only start 2. So I can afford to wait a year.

I tried to trade down a couple of spots, but no serious offers. At spot #4 your looking at Spiller and Tate in this league. Should one of the other top 3 fall instead of Spiller, then IMO it isn't an issue.

Then take Demaryious Thomas, who could probably start for you this year, and target a rookie RB next year.

-oo-

[BradyT]

Never let situation fool you and make you passing up on the better talent. Take Spiller!

[KU Sucks]

I actually don't need rb production right away. I have Mendy, Grant, Charles, & J. Stew; and can only start 2. So I can afford to wait a year.

I tried to trade down a couple of spots, but no serious offers. At spot #4 your looking at Spiller and Tate in this league. Should one of the other top 3 fall instead of Spiller, then IMO it isn't an issue.

Then take Demaryious Thomas, who could probably start for you this year, and target a rookie RB next year.

-oo-

As of now I will be targeting wrs @ 2.2 & 2.4. I'm too much of rb whore not to take one @ 1.4.

[meineymoe]

I actually don't need rb production right away. I have Mendy, Grant, Charles, & J. Stew; and can only start 2. So I can afford to wait a year.

I tried to trade down a couple of spots, but no serious offers. At spot #4 your looking at Spiller and Tate in this league. Should one of the other top 3 fall instead of Spiller, then IMO it isn't an issue.

Then take Demaryious Thomas, who could probably start for you this year, and target a rookie RB next year.

-oo-

As of now I will be targeting wrs @ 2.2 & 2.4. I'm too much of rb whore not to take one @ 1.4.

I hear that. Then fly with Spiller if he's there - definitely the sexier pick!

-oo-

[rkrazy]

Spiller...he's the better talent and will rise to the top in Buffalo eventually. Houston is the place where all promising backs seem to fade away too soon.

Since I drafted Tate @ 1.05 in one league I sure hope I'm wrong about that last comment.

[hostile]

Draft talent over situation.

Spiller has talent. His situation is not as bad as many think.

[pvballer3915]

spiller for sure

[GridIronFavre]

I will be the lone wolf here and say Tate. Despite liking Tate, this is more of a knock on Spiller from my standpoint - I have never liked Spiller because of how much he reminds me of Reggie Bush.

[blacksheep]

Spiller on the board at 1.4 is a gift.

x2