Ryan for romo Prescott and a third

[Mstuart2]

Which one does everyone prefer?? I am rebuilding so the prize is the pick and Prescitt. The other owner has offered to sub Kaepernick for Romo

[Eight7Seven]

Matt Ryan and for me by a mile. Matt Ryan is five years younger then Romo and doesn't have a single injury concern. Romo has dealt with serious injuries over the last three seasons. I don't have any faith in Prescott ever veing handed the keys to the franchise and he'd be the wprst of your already overloaded group of rookie QB's. A third round pick in a 16 team league is not nearly enticing enough to trade your only bankable asset at QB.

[SpartyOn]

Agree with the above, hold Ryan here.

[bonscott]

Yes, Matt Ryan all the way. Why is Prescott the prize here? Like any other long shot QB he could very easily be out of football in 2 years. If you really like Prescott then go get him for a 3rd or 4th, but don't trade away a QB in his prime for a prospect with a 10-20% chance of ever starting an NFL game.

[Coogan Football]

Definitely Matty Ice, especially in a 16 teamer

[FantasyFreak]

Don't let a preseason game tip the scale. Take Matty ice.

[derekhiny]

Ryan by a long ways. I think one preseason game is seriously clouding your judgment. They mean nothing. Vanilla game plans, soft coverages from defenses, no designer blitzes, etc. Dak was the 8th QB taken in this draft class for a reason. He has a long ways to go in his developmental process, and it's certainly far from assured that he'll be the future starting QB in Dallas. If you make this trade, there's a better than average chance you'll look back on it two years from now and realize you gave away Matt Ryan for a much older, more frail QB and a dart throw pick in the late 30s.