Im I crazy to offer up this much for DGB?

[jagsguy92]

i give 1.02

i get DGB, karlos williams

[jagsguy92]

What side would you take here? i believe DGB is gonna explode so its a matter of if this trade is nuts or not?

[CurtisMyFavMartin]

Not me, I'll take the 1.02 and draft Treadwell or Elliot. I don't trust DGB's off the field issues enough to invest that heavily.

[jagsguy92]

what if the karlos williams became lesean? or buck allen?

[Plank]

DGB still has a lot to learn .. think we'll see flashes the next two years, but if he blows up, it might be as late as his 4th year..

[sugbear65]

I've been a DGB believer, so I'm prob as high as anyone in him. And I like Karlos enough, he's def more than just a throw in. So, being a guy who liked and drafted DGB, and now have held him through his rookie season where he showed some flashes and gained valuable experience, I'm even more excited about him for the future. So it would take more than 1.02 for me to move DGB. MAYBE I would do it if Elliot was there and I thought I was a RB away from the championship I would think about it. That would have to be on the clock though and a little further down the draft process. But that's just for DGB. You want Karlos too? If he feels about DGB that way as well, expect a rejection.

[Jfever]

Not me, I'll take the 1.02 and draft Treadwell or Elliot. I don't trust DGB's off the field issues enough to invest that heavily.

What off the field issues? No news is good news typically, and I've heard nothing at all about DGB. Nothing. Please let me know what I've missed as it is possible I've missed something. Been quite busy lately.

Now, I've no problems with someone valuing Treadwell or Elliot, or even a couple others a bit more as prospects, but, using "off the field worries" - isn't really (in my opinion) a valid excuse.

Just my opinion.

[ddog2303]

He was removed from a college team for off the field issues. I haven't heard anything new at all. So for a guy with past issues, no news is certainly good news. I strongly feel that Williams will replace McCoy in the next 2-3 and make it a time share before that. But I think your situation matters a bit. If you think DGB or Karlos will help you then sure. But Treadwell will more than likely go to a team where he'll be able to contribute something almost right away. So like I said, your situation matters. If it's me, I take Treadwell. If Treadwell isn't there I'd take Zeke. But, your pick will be worth more so if you don't want those guys, move the pick during the draft. It'll bring in more assets the closer to the draft you get.

[Bad News Barrett]

I'd rather have one of the two potential studs of the draft. Williams is good, but behind McCoy for a few years. DGB, I don't know, he's showed a little, but I'm far from convinced. I don't trust dumb players. Less than half the game is athleticism, ask Christine Michael, Cordarelle Patterson, or Justin Hunter about how far their athleticism has gotten them...

[Cameron Giles]

I'd rather have 1.02.

[Shcritters]

I would rather have the 1.02. If it were the 1.03 or 1.04 I would seriously consider it, but this is another draft where the bust potential goes up after the first two picks (in my opinion). If you want safe(r) keep the pick.

[iluvbeer99]

1.02 by quite a bit.

[snownerdy]

I would take DGB. I'm not high on Tred and prefer Micheal Thomas over him.

[TomBobAnderson]

I would wait till the draft. If Treadwell goes number 1, go get DGB and Karlos. If Elliot goes number 1, take Treadwell.