So that’s a totally valid point! I would just say that if that’s your point, I probably wouldn’t title the thread “Why is Mike Evans so disliked in the fantasy community” because it seems like as a whole the community values him just fine. (I know you didn’t start the thread, CGW, just making the point.)CGW wrote: ↑Sun Feb 07, 2021 12:26 pmADP wise I think hes ranked just fine. I might have him ahead of Higgins or mclaurin but fully get the age argument of either of them ahead of him. Where his value seems to be off is in the price you pay. All of the above list cost a mid to early 1st at least. Evans, as seen in the trades listed in this thread and elsewhere, can often be had for a late 1st or less. His value discrepancy seems to be price rather than ranking.
I also agree with your rankings, and I might actually prefer him to Michael Thomas post-Brees to be honest, but I’ll also probably have JuJu ahead of him this off-season.
I agree that it’s crazy to get a player valued as a fringe WR1 in ADP for a second, but I don’t think that this phenomenon is unique to Mike Evans either.