AJ Brown or DJ Moore?

[hoos89]

AJB year 1 > Moore year 1
AJB year 1 = Moore year 2
AJB year 2 > Moore year 3
AJB #1 on team > Moore #2 on team (currently)
Tannehill > Bridgewater

Both are studs and will be future studs but who knows when will Moore situation change? I'll take AJB cause his situation, usage, and qb seems to be stable, instead of hoping Moore situation gets better in 1-3 years.

I don't really think AJB year 1 = Moore year 2 is fair. DJM was WR12 in total points and AJB was WR23 last year.

I also don't really think that the AJB #1 / DJM #2 argument is fair at all...seems like super selective reasoning. There's only been 1 week where Anderson significantly outscored DJM, which happens to be the same number of weeks DJM has significantly outscored Anderson. Otherwise they've been within a few points either way, and their season total is fairly close as well so I think they're really more like 1a/1b.
Also Davis has not been out-targeted by AJB yet this season in a game where both played and Davis has significantly outscored AJB two out of three games in which they both played vs AJB significantly outscoring Davis once.

[The MAC Machine]

DJM was WR12 in total points and AJB was WR23 last year.

Sorry, but this is inaccurate. DJM was WR 16 and AJB was 21.

[hoos89]

DJM was WR12 in total points and AJB was WR23 last year.

Sorry, but this is inaccurate. DJM was WR 16 and AJB was 21.

It's accurate for the fantasy season (weeks 1-16). I'm guessing this is if you include week 17? I don't because MFL doesn't show it (also it's not part of the fantasy season for a reason).

[JJRules]

DJM was WR12 in total points and AJB was WR23 last year.

Sorry, but this is inaccurate. DJM was WR 16 and AJB was 21.

I just checked my league histories, and last year:

non-PPR
AJB finished WR8
DJM finished WR21

.5 PPR
AJB finished WR15
DJM finished WR18

[hoos89]

Full PPR then

[Sriracha]

Full PPR then

AJ wasn't even a full time starter until week 10.

[hoos89]

Full PPR then

AJ wasn't even a full time starter until week 10.

Are we going to make the same caveat for DJM's rookie season?

[Sriracha]

Full PPR then

AJ wasn't even a full time starter until week 10.

Are we going to make the same caveat for DJM's rookie season?

Of course DJM was afforded that caveat as a rookie.

No one is comparing AJB's rookie season to DJM's rookies season; they're comparing AJB's rookie season to DJM's 2nd season.

[Mjvb5]

AJ wasn't even a full time starter until week 10.

Are we going to make the same caveat for DJM's rookie season?

Of course DJM was afforded that caveat as a rookie.

No one is comparing AJB's rookie season to DJM's rookies season; they're comparing AJB's rookie season to DJM's 2nd season.

Even leaving out, not having full time reps and the huge increase in production from tannehill. The reality is AJB scored more points in 2/3 scoring formats.

[trc]

Even leaving out, not having full time reps and the huge increase in production from tannehill. The reality is AJB scored more points in 2/3 scoring formats.

What formats are you referring to?
DJ seems to win in all PPR-formats
AJB will win non-ppr, depending on TD-scoring and perhaps depending on return yards, as it seems very close in standard leagues.

[hankmurphy]

I feel like the tape speaks for itself.

[Mjvb5]

Even leaving out, not having full time reps and the huge increase in production from tannehill. The reality is AJB scored more points in 2/3 scoring formats.

What formats are you referring to?
DJ seems to win in all PPR-formats
AJB will win non-ppr, depending on TD-scoring and perhaps depending on return yards, as it seems very close in standard leagues.

AJB scored more points in his rookie year in both half ppr and non ppr than dj Moore did in his sophomore year

[Jigga94]

Even leaving out, not having full time reps and the huge increase in production from tannehill. The reality is AJB scored more points in 2/3 scoring formats.

What formats are you referring to?
DJ seems to win in all PPR-formats
AJB will win non-ppr, depending on TD-scoring and perhaps depending on return yards, as it seems very close in standard leagues.

AJB scored more points in his rookie year in both half ppr and non ppr than dj Moore did in his sophomore year

Good thing I only play in full ppr!

Just poking a little fun this should be a good thread for a while. Going to take a while to settle it, I bet

[jjleurquin]

What formats are you referring to?
DJ seems to win in all PPR-formats
AJB will win non-ppr, depending on TD-scoring and perhaps depending on return yards, as it seems very close in standard leagues.

AJB scored more points in his rookie year in both half ppr and non ppr than dj Moore did in his sophomore year

Good thing I only play in full ppr!

Just poking a little fun this should be a good thread for a while. Going to take a while to settle it, I bet

I think the DK/AJB comparison is much closer.

[Jigga94]

AJB scored more points in his rookie year in both half ppr and non ppr than dj Moore did in his sophomore year

Good thing I only play in full ppr!

Just poking a little fun this should be a good thread for a while. Going to take a while to settle it, I bet

I think the DK/AJB comparison is much closer.

I wouldn't disagree. Maybe we need that thread too? Lol