Shenault = S.O.D?

[kadun2]

^ yeah, he’s an all-out dude. That can be good and bad

[DLF3000]

Like Shenault. Not thrilled about him being a Jaguar - that actually bothers me more than his injury history.

Look forward to seeing what Shenault can do with The Stache out there, but similar to Mims, not expecting much his rookie year.

[DLF3000]

Great start for Shenault! Not too many rookie wideouts making huge noise so far Week 1, was great to see him score.

Can't ask for much more as a rookie wideout this year, nevermind one on the Jags and vs. a supposed playoff team in the Colts.

[Sriracha]

Shenault did this on a 29% snap share...

I'm buying

[PPE82]

Bumping.

Thoughts after solid but under the radar rookie year and with Lawrence likely coming to Jac?

[dark_knite03]

He's right there with Boyd and Deebo range for me. However if I was going to gamble on a jags wr I'd rather have Chark.

[Sriracha]

He's right there with Boyd and Deebo range for me. However if I was going to gamble on a jags wr I'd rather have Chark.

Chark: Age 24, YPRR 1.47, Target premium .1%, Air yard share 34.3% (#14)
Shenault: Age 22, YPRR 1.56, Target Premium + 27.5%, Air yard share 12.1% (#98)

Given that these guys were both somewhat raw prospects, we can also compare their rookie seasons:
Chark: 11 GP 14 REC, 174 yards
Shenault: 14 GP 58 REC, 600 yards 5TDs

Even in his breakout campaign: Chark 15 games, 1008 yards and 8TDs... people seem to talk about Chark as if he's a known stud or something but it wouldn't surprise me if he settled in as an elite #2 deep threat (like Will Fuller). Shenault with his alpha frame, athleticism and YAC ability is more suited to the #1 role if he can develop a bit more as a route runner.

Shenault is likely the WR to own in this offense -- especially with Urban Meyers coming to town.

[Shankopotamus]

He's right there with Boyd and Deebo range for me. However if I was going to gamble on a jags wr I'd rather have Chark.

Chark: Age 24, YPRR 1.47, Target premium .1%, Air yard share 34.3% (#14)
Shenault: Age 22, YPRR 1.56, Target Premium + 27.5%, Air yard share 12.1% (#98)

Given that these guys were both somewhat raw prospects, we can also compare their rookie seasons:
Chark: 11 GP 14 REC, 174 yards
Shenault: 14 GP 58 REC, 600 yards 5TDs

Even in his breakout campaign: Chark 15 games, 1008 yards and 8TDs... people seem to talk about Chark as if he's a known stud or something but it wouldn't surprise me if he settled in as an elite #2 deep threat (like Will Fuller). Shenault with his alpha frame, athleticism and YAC ability is more suited to the #1 role if he can develop a bit more as a route runner.

Shenault is likely the WR to own in this offense -- especially with Urban Meyers coming to town.

Agreed, but health is still a concern for me.

[KingsKing]

He's right there with Boyd and Deebo range for me. However if I was going to gamble on a jags wr I'd rather have Chark.

Chark: Age 24, YPRR 1.47, Target premium .1%, Air yard share 34.3% (#14)
Shenault: Age 22, YPRR 1.56, Target Premium + 27.5%, Air yard share 12.1% (#98)

Given that these guys were both somewhat raw prospects, we can also compare their rookie seasons:
Chark: 11 GP 14 REC, 174 yards
Shenault: 14 GP 58 REC, 600 yards 5TDs

Even in his breakout campaign: Chark 15 games, 1008 yards and 8TDs... people seem to talk about Chark as if he's a known stud or something but it wouldn't surprise me if he settled in as an elite #2 deep threat (like Will Fuller). Shenault with his alpha frame, athleticism and YAC ability is more suited to the #1 role if he can develop a bit more as a route runner.

Shenault is likely the WR to own in this offense -- especially with Urban Meyers coming to town.

You may end up being right but if we are talking prototype wr builds and athletic ability Chark is the Alpha in the room .

Shenault is 6'1 and 220 lbs , ran the 40 in 4.58 , 1.61 10 yard split, 9 inch hands, 31 inch arms , no vert or broad jump recorded.

Clark is 6'4 and 200 lbs , ran the 40 in 4.34, 1.51 10 yard split, 9.25 inch hands, 32 inch arms, 40 inch vert and 129 inch broad jump. Those are elite alpha athletic numbers and more in line with a WR1 frame.

His breakout season of 73/1008/8 also came in 15 games which is very impressive for anyone, let alone a 2nd year WR.

I think whoever gels with Lawrence best will end up being the WR1 on this team, ill take the gamble with Clark based on previous production, size, athletic ability and the fact he is physically a clone to Tee Higgins and Justyn Ross who Lawrence has been throwing to for the last 3 seasons. With that being said I don't see why they cant sustain 2 fantasy viable wr's .

[Sriracha]

He's right there with Boyd and Deebo range for me. However if I was going to gamble on a jags wr I'd rather have Chark.

Chark: Age 24, YPRR 1.47, Target premium .1%, Air yard share 34.3% (#14)
Shenault: Age 22, YPRR 1.56, Target Premium + 27.5%, Air yard share 12.1% (#98)

Given that these guys were both somewhat raw prospects, we can also compare their rookie seasons:
Chark: 11 GP 14 REC, 174 yards
Shenault: 14 GP 58 REC, 600 yards 5TDs

Even in his breakout campaign: Chark 15 games, 1008 yards and 8TDs... people seem to talk about Chark as if he's a known stud or something but it wouldn't surprise me if he settled in as an elite #2 deep threat (like Will Fuller). Shenault with his alpha frame, athleticism and YAC ability is more suited to the #1 role if he can develop a bit more as a route runner.

Shenault is likely the WR to own in this offense -- especially with Urban Meyers coming to town.

You may end up being right but if we are talking prototype wr builds and athletic ability Chark is the Alpha in the room .

Shenault is 6'1 and 220 lbs , ran the 40 in 4.58 , 1.61 10 yard split, 9 inch hands, 31 inch arms , no vert or broad jump recorded.

Clark is 6'4 and 200 lbs , ran the 40 in 4.34, 1.51 10 yard split, 9.25 inch hands, 32 inch arms, 40 inch vert and 129 inch broad jump. Those are elite alpha athletic numbers and more in line with a WR1 frame.

His breakout season of 73/1008/8 also came in 15 games which is very impressive for anyone, let alone a 2nd year WR.

I think whoever gels with Lawrence best will end up being the WR1 on this team, ill take the gamble with Clark based on previous production, size, athletic ability and the fact he is physically a clone to Tee Higgins and Justyn Ross who Lawrence has been throwing to for the last 3 seasons. With that being said I don't see why they cant sustain 2 fantasy viable wr's .

You really think Shenault runs a 4.6?

[KingsKing]

I don't think he does, I actually know he does because thats what he ran at the combine

[YouMightDieTryin]

I think someone else said it before in a different thread, but if you're trying to acquire one of them I'd rather pay for Shenault at this price over Chark at his.

The other factors to bring in:
Will it be Lawrence at #1? (Duh?)
Who will their QB prefer? We've seen it in CAR with Robby/DJ on who's "better", but who's schemed for? So Meyer could dictate that.

[CGW]

I think someone else said it before in a different thread, but if you're trying to acquire one of them I'd rather pay for Shenault at this price over Chark at his.

The other factors to bring in:
Will it be Lawrence at #1? (Duh?)
Who will their QB prefer? We've seen it in CAR with Robby/DJ on who's "better", but who's schemed for? So Meyer could dictate that.

Yep, give me the cheaper of the options. I'll pay for Shenault and Johnson over paying a significant premium for Chark.

[OhCruelestRanter]

I don't think he does, I actually know he does because thats what he ran at the combine

He was hurt.

It’s possible that these two are both elite options with Lawrence.

It’s also possible that Jacksonville signs a big time FA WR and this becomes a mess.

[Sriracha]

I don't think he does, I actually know he does because thats what he ran at the combine

So out of curiosity, do you know why he ran so few drills at the combine?