2020 BAD Trade Offers

[Jigga94]

Got this one for Rowdy Raccoons team (in sig) today:

I give: CEH, Juju, and a 4th.
I "get": Mixon, Kupp, and a 3rd.

This doesn't belong here

[ThunderTung]

Got this one for Rowdy Raccoons team (in sig) today:

I give: CEH, Juju, and a 4th.
I "get": Mixon, Kupp, and a 3rd.

This doesn't belong here

here we go again lol

[MucBuc]

Give: Singletary + 2021 first-rounder
Get: Philip Rivers + 2023 second-rounder

Granted, it's a 32 team league, but I still have zero need for Rivers on that team.

[CGW]

SF

Give: Rodgers, Dobbins
Get: Michel, Hurts, 2021 2nd(early), 2022 1st (prob late)

I feel this belongs here...

[treble83]

Got this one for Rowdy Raccoons team (in sig) today:

I give: CEH, Juju, and a 4th.
I "get": Mixon, Kupp, and a 3rd.

This doesn't belong here

Incorrect

[hoos89]

Got this one for Rowdy Raccoons team (in sig) today:

I give: CEH, Juju, and a 4th.
I "get": Mixon, Kupp, and a 3rd.

This doesn't belong here

Incorrect

It's not the worst offer I've ever seen but it's very bad. Juju arguably more valuable than Mixon right now and CEH might be more valuable than Mixon ever was.

[jenkins.math]

This doesn't belong here

Incorrect

It's not the worst offer I've ever seen but it's very bad. Juju arguably more valuable than Mixon right now and CEH might be more valuable than Mixon ever was.

So Kupp is irrelevant in this equation? I can see people prefering Kupp to Juju straight up. I think the value is on the CEH side, but I don't think it's worthy of being in this thread.

[hoos89]

Incorrect

It's not the worst offer I've ever seen but it's very bad. Juju arguably more valuable than Mixon right now and CEH might be more valuable than Mixon ever was.

So Kupp is irrelevant in this equation? I can see people prefering Kupp to Juju straight up. I think the value is on the CEH side, but I don't think it's worthy of being in this thread.

No, I'm just saying the 2 most valuable pieces on the trade are on one side, which usually qualifies as a bad offer.

[Shoreline Steamers]

I wasn't involved and cannot directly verify, but the guy is a good friend and I trust him. He was offered the opportunity to:


Give Jonathan Taylor
Get Benny Snell Jr.

...and he's a Badger fan.

Had one in my inbox this morning, it's for a keeper league (so not true dynasty) but the offer was:

Send: Jonathan Taylor
Get: Todd Gurley

I just let the other owner know I was planning on Taylor being a keeper moving forward. Gurley not so much.

[Jigga94]

It's not the worst offer I've ever seen but it's very bad. Juju arguably more valuable than Mixon right now and CEH might be more valuable than Mixon ever was.

So Kupp is irrelevant in this equation? I can see people prefering Kupp to Juju straight up. I think the value is on the CEH side, but I don't think it's worthy of being in this thread.

No, I'm just saying the 2 most valuable pieces on the trade are on one side, which usually qualifies as a bad offer.

The fact that there's disagreement on that point alone proves it's not a BAD offer. This isn't CEH for Darrel williams. Do I prefer CEH to Mixon? Yes. Juju and Kupp are pretty close though and a 3rd is better than a 4th. Pretty good starting offer if you ask me. The deal could go either way

[treble83]

Mixon has far less upside than CEH (fairly common opinion) and although Juju and Kupp are similar in value, Kupp tore his ACL a year or two ago. Juju has a much better injury history. The rookie draft picks are insignificant here as they are not 1st or 2nd round. In my defense, this thread is titled "bad trade offers" not "awful trade offers."

[Jigga94]

Mixon has far less upside than CEH (fairly common opinion) and although Juju and Kupp are similar in value, Kupp tore his ACL a year or two ago. Juju has a much better injury history. The rookie draft picks are insignificant here as they are not 1st or 2nd round. In my defense, this thread is titled "bad trade offers" not "awful trade offers."

And the year after his ACL tear he had 96/1161/10 and played all 16 games so I fail to see your point about the injury. An ACL is a random occurrence. It isn't more likely to occur again. Meanwhile Juju had 42/552/3 last year in only 12 games hmmmm.

It's actually BAD trade threads. I assume the all caps = awful

[hoos89]

Kupp is generally materially behind JuJu in trade value, but even IF it's close, the gap between CEH and Mixon is very big at the moment.

[Jigga94]

"BAD" offers people posted about 3 years ago

Some are actually BAD and would never work out...

I give: M. Thomas
I get: L. Green & Cj. Fedorowizc

I give: M. Thomas & Toddy Gurley
I get: Rawls & DGB

Then there's some that aren't that BAD and could even swing the other way fairly easily.

Give: David Johnson and Josh Doctson
Get: Deandre Hopkins

I give: Todd Gurley
I get: Tyreek Hill

Just sayin...

[ThunderTung]

Mixon has far less upside than CEH (fairly common opinion) and although Juju and Kupp are similar in value, Kupp tore his ACL a year or two ago. Juju has a much better injury history. The rookie draft picks are insignificant here as they are not 1st or 2nd round. In my defense, this thread is titled "bad trade offers" not "awful trade offers."

The point he's making is no one wants to see kind of bad offers. This thread is for laughable offers. that trade could be worked out fairly easily. However, like shoreline steamer, J.Taylor for Gurley straight up is a laughable offer and probably wont go anywhere further