Josh Jacobs Value - Poll

[bigcsr67]

I’m not sure why you would want to sell Jacobs at this point. He has proven he is the real deal. Unless you are stacked at RB, and need WR help, there is no way I’m dealing a now proven talent for a crap shoot 2020 1st, not even the 1.1 next year. He’s looking like an absolute stud.

[Phaded]

At the time I doubted myself, was scared it was just me being optimistic as a Raiders fan - but now I'm happy with it. I traded Bell for 1.01 and then drafted Jacobs.

Top 10, easily.

[rubber_duck]

The year after Larry Johnson broke out he had 2,200 scrimmage yards, 19 TDs and 375 total fantasy points. I mean sure he fell off after that, but that trade easily could have cost you a championship depending on what the haul was.

It sounds like you’re trying to win an internet argument.

You asked if I would still sell, and I responded ‘yes’. Jacobs still looks like an average NFL talent to that is in a situation to succeed. He is currently succeeding. If I trade him for fair value now, then great. It won’t matter at all if my evaluation is correct or not.

As a bonus, I would probably be making a profit on Jacobs at the same time.

[hoos89]

.....you think Jacobs looks like an average NFL talent? Have you actually been watching? Teams don't typically draft average NFL talents in the 1st round, particularly at the RB position (and QB aside). Average NFL talents can't do this:

https://www.raiders.com/video/josh-jaco ... at-packers

[FantasyFreak]

The year after Larry Johnson broke out he had 2,200 scrimmage yards, 19 TDs and 375 total fantasy points. I mean sure he fell off after that, but that trade easily could have cost you a championship depending on what the haul was.

It sounds like you’re trying to win an internet argument.

You asked if I would still sell, and I responded ‘yes’. Jacobs still looks like an average NFL talent to that is in a situation to succeed. He is currently succeeding. If I trade him for fair value now, then great. It won’t matter at all if my evaluation is correct or not.

As a bonus, I would probably be making a profit on Jacobs at the same time.

Can't understand this statement at all. Jacobs consistently creates yards on his own. Miles Sanders and David Montgomery would not be doing what Jacobs is doing in the same situation. He's clearly an above average back.

[Forza_Azzurri]

The year after Larry Johnson broke out he had 2,200 scrimmage yards, 19 TDs and 375 total fantasy points. I mean sure he fell off after that, but that trade easily could have cost you a championship depending on what the haul was.

It sounds like you’re trying to win an internet argument.

You asked if I would still sell, and I responded ‘yes’. Jacobs still looks like an average NFL talent to that is in a situation to succeed. He is currently succeeding. If I trade him for fair value now, then great. It won’t matter at all if my evaluation is correct or not.

As a bonus, I would probably be making a profit on Jacobs at the same time.

Jacobs is PFF’s highest graded RB by some margin (17.6 points) ... only FB, DE & K have larger gaps between #1 & #2 rankings.