2019 Bad Trade Offers

[jomaed]

I'd say that's a great offer in a rookie draft.
Ya got Murray and Jacobs as the typical 1 and 2 then a slight drop to monty, sanders, harry, and haskins in most peoples eyes

Its a horrible offer. Especially in a rookie draft. Adding a 2nd to move up one spot in a draft as wide open as this one?

It's trash.

The top 3 rb and top 2 qb are in the same tier for me.

its not a bad offer. your personal views of not caring to be at spot 2 or spot 5 doesnt matter. totally legit offer

This was the exact offer that needed to happen to move up that 1 spot. I accepted nearly the exact offer in my league and actually thought I let guy moving from 3 to 2 actually off pretty cheap.

[Hankybro21]

This is it. This has to be the winner. I lost Luck so am looking for veteran QB help. 10 team, 1 QB league. Ask the Rivers owner and this gem comes out

Get: Philip Rivers
Give: Michael Thomas

I say no. He says I can counter. I say no, we are nowhere near close. He gets all pissy. Sigh.

[FantasyFreak]

This is it. This has to be the winner. I lost Luck so am looking for veteran QB help. 10 team, 1 QB league. Ask the Rivers owner and this gem comes out

Get: Philip Rivers
Give: Michael Thomas

I say no. He says I can counter. I say no, we are nowhere near close. He gets all pissy. Sigh.

He's a azz hat. Don't sigh, have fun with him on counters.

[SteelLake]

Trade Carson Wentz, receive LeSean McCoy.

League is transitioning to superflex next year

[Jcedwards]

SEND: Aaron Jones
RECEIVE: Pettis, Ronald Jones, 2020 2nd (probably late)

1. I'm out of room at WR, so I'd have to drop one of my active WRs, which I'm not doing
2. Ronald Jones does nothing for me
3. Guy's 2nd that he has won the league last year, so very well will be close to a 3rd

[Jigga94]

SEND: Aaron Jones
RECEIVE: Pettis, Ronald Jones, 2020 2nd (probably late)

1. I'm out of room at WR, so I'd have to drop one of my active WRs, which I'm not doing
2. Ronald Jones does nothing for me
3. Guy's 2nd that he has won the league last year, so very well will be close to a 3rd

That's not that bad. Besides I'd rather have Pettis than Fitz. Still wouldn't accept though but it's a good starting offer

[Prison_Mike]

SEND: Aaron Jones
RECEIVE: Pettis, Ronald Jones, 2020 2nd (probably late)

1. I'm out of room at WR, so I'd have to drop one of my active WRs, which I'm not doing
2. Ronald Jones does nothing for me
3. Guy's 2nd that he has won the league last year, so very well will be close to a 3rd

That's not that bad. Besides I'd rather have Pettis than Fitz. Still wouldn't accept though but it's a good starting offer

Agreed that it seems pretty close based on value.
This seems to be an example of someone disregarding YOUR roster construction, and sending a trade that only benefits them

[Flgatorguy87]

I am the Luck owner, so the Brisett owner wants to send me some help and be a nice guy.

Brisett for Diggs and my early 2020 1st (likely top 3, and leading candidate for 1st overall).


How thoughtful of this guy.

[NanceUSMC]

I'm a (bad) Luck owner, but also have Cam, so his retirement didn't just kill me... Regardless, I was just offered Russell Wilson in exchange for DeAndre Hopkins....

*facepalm*

[StripesOfKC]

Lost Luck in a 1QB league and got offered Kirk Cousins and a 4th round rookie draft pick for my Hockenson, Parris Campbell, Daniel Jones, Darrell Henderson and a 1st round rookie draft pick.
Guy went on to drop Kirk Cousins hours after I declined

[whodunnit]

Get: Mebane, Verrett
Give : Marlon Mack


In this league Mebane got 60 points last year. Verrett is nothing.

[whodunnit]

its not a bad offer. your personal views of not caring to be at spot 2 or spot 5 doesnt matter. totally legit offer

So you would trade Montgomery and say, Parris Campbell for Jacobs and like, Alex Barnes or some other nobody? That makes sense.

[Jigga94]

Lost Luck in a 1QB league and got offered Kirk Cousins and a 4th round rookie draft pick for my Hockenson, Parris Campbell, Daniel Jones, Darrell Henderson and a 1st round rookie draft pick.
Guy went on to drop Kirk Cousins hours after I declined

Wow, had he come with a reasonable offer, maybe he could've got something for Cousins instead of nothing

[IR1]

Lost Luck in a 1QB league and got offered Kirk Cousins and a 4th round rookie draft pick for my Hockenson, Parris Campbell, Daniel Jones, Darrell Henderson and a 1st round rookie draft pick.
Guy went on to drop Kirk Cousins hours after I declined

Wow, had he come with a reasonable offer, maybe he could've got something for Cousins instead of nothing

Had the same thought, depending on OP QB's, Cousins for one of the players would have been reasonable

[Patsfan86]

I love this thread since it shows all of our collective thoughts on all players values. I always try to think of team situations when i offer a trade. For instance i am very much overvaluing Kalen Ballage on my team. Ive gotten good offers at face value but they are bad for my team and my specific situation. Some owners around dynasty dont seem to understand the situational piece when they offer a trade. I am in a rebuild and i want to keep ballage to see if he is anything or get overpaid because im in a rebuild and he is a young RB. If i were to post some of these trade offers ive gotten for ballage many on here would say it wasnt a bad offer, it doesnt belong in this thread, and they would be right, however i felt it was bad for my team.