2019 Bad Trade Offers

[Hankybro21]

Give Sony
Get 2019 late 2nd and late 3rd

[whodunnit]

I got an offer tonight:
I give - 1.03/2.03
I get - 1.02/6.02

Sf league

[bjd5211]

I got an offer tonight:
I give - 1.03/2.03
I get - 1.02/6.02

Sf league

Rookie draft or startup?

Because in a startup while ya it's probably still a bit rich, I have a rather large gap in value between picks 2 and 3. Top 2 picks in a SF league mean I'm getting Mahomes or Barkley, 3 and lower I'm probably not. You'll have to "overpay" me to move back just the one spot.

Rookie draft, ya that's trash.

[whodunnit]

I got an offer tonight:
I give - 1.03/2.03
I get - 1.02/6.02

Sf league

Rookie draft or startup?

Because in a startup while ya it's probably still a bit rich, I have a rather large gap in value between picks 2 and 3. Top 2 picks in a SF league mean I'm getting Mahomes or Barkley, 3 and lower I'm probably not. You'll have to "overpay" me to move back just the one spot.

Rookie draft, ya that's trash.

Rookie draft

[bjd5211]

Then ya, terrible offer.

[Mjvb5]

I got an offer tonight:
I give - 1.03/2.03
I get - 1.02/6.02

Sf league

Rookie draft or startup?

Because in a startup while ya it's probably still a bit rich, I have a rather large gap in value between picks 2 and 3. Top 2 picks in a SF league mean I'm getting Mahomes or Barkley, 3 and lower I'm probably not. You'll have to "overpay" me to move back just the one spot.

Rookie draft, ya that's trash.

Rookie draft

I'd say that's a great offer in a rookie draft.
Ya got Murray and Jacobs as the typical 1 and 2 then a slight drop to monty, sanders, harry, and haskins in most peoples eyes

[TimeWillTell]

Rookie draft or startup?

Because in a startup while ya it's probably still a bit rich, I have a rather large gap in value between picks 2 and 3. Top 2 picks in a SF league mean I'm getting Mahomes or Barkley, 3 and lower I'm probably not. You'll have to "overpay" me to move back just the one spot.

Rookie draft, ya that's trash.

Rookie draft

I'd say that's a great offer in a rookie draft.
Ya got Murray and Jacobs as the typical 1 and 2 then a slight drop to monty, sanders, harry, and haskins in most peoples eyes

Yeah idk why people think this is a bad offer. It's not a steal by any means but it's def not bad for a rookie draft. A 2nd is a pretty standard price to move up, plus you get a 6th coming back? Not too bad imo.

[whodunnit]

Rookie draft or startup?

Because in a startup while ya it's probably still a bit rich, I have a rather large gap in value between picks 2 and 3. Top 2 picks in a SF league mean I'm getting Mahomes or Barkley, 3 and lower I'm probably not. You'll have to "overpay" me to move back just the one spot.

Rookie draft, ya that's trash.

Rookie draft

I'd say that's a great offer in a rookie draft.
Ya got Murray and Jacobs as the typical 1 and 2 then a slight drop to monty, sanders, harry, and haskins in most peoples eyes

Its a horrible offer. Especially in a rookie draft. Adding a 2nd to move up one spot in a draft as wide open as this one?

It's trash.

The top 3 rb and top 2 qb are in the same tier for me.

[petebusey]

Rookie draft

I'd say that's a great offer in a rookie draft.
Ya got Murray and Jacobs as the typical 1 and 2 then a slight drop to monty, sanders, harry, and haskins in most peoples eyes

Its a horrible offer. Especially in a rookie draft. Adding a 2nd to move up one spot in a draft as wide open as this one?

It's trash.

The top 3 rb and top 2 qb are in the same tier for me.

Yeah, I don't see it as too lopsided of a trade at all either. Especially if anyone has Jacobs in a tier above any other players (other than Murray) in a SF league. I think that trade is about as fair as it gets for anyone with a strong preference for non K.Murray player above the rest of the field in a SF rookie draft. Surprised this trade was posted in the Bad Trade Offers topic.

@ whodunnit -- if it's not an offer that you like, it doesn't mean it's a bad offer (I guess we are getting into semantics of "bad offer" and it is somewhat subjective). If you have the top 5 players in the same tier, I'd try to trade down to pick 1.04 or 1.05 and gain a little something extra.

[IR1]

I’ll vote bad, why move back 4 rounds when the top 4-5 are similar tier

[Mephistopheles]

Give AJG, get Lamar Miller and Devin Funchess.
Miller would be my 5th best back and all the WR on my roster are better than Funchess. Plus I don't have anyone I would want to drop to accommodate the extra roster spot.

Yes I realize AJG is hurt but this return is completely worthless to me.
Seems like more and more that the idiots playing this game just don't think things through...just click random players.

Update on this one.
This dip bleep puts a note in the league message board that "Lamar Miller is available for a reasonable cost", then proceeds to offer Miller for AJG straight up. SMFH.
And people wonder why I hate trading...

[bjd5211]

I don't think AJ Green for Lamar Miller straight up is very far off at this point, and I own AJ but no Miller shares.

[Blueboy]

I don't think AJ Green for Lamar Miller straight up is very far off at this point, and I own AJ but no Miller shares.

The market value may be trending that way, but if I can get AJG for my Miller share I'll be doing it in a heartbeat.

[bjd5211]

I'm not saying people should do it, or that they are even, but they are not so far apart the AJ owner should be insulted by the offer.

[BigBawseRoss]

12 team must start 2 qb, 3 rb, 4 wr

send Prescott, P. Campbell

get D Henry and a late 2020 2nd.