2019 Bad Trade Offers

[jordanzs]

Get 1.1
Give 1.2, 1.3

That would've been a smash-accept last year

Or in Zeke's rookie year

Or Gurley's rookie year

But yeah, 2019 ain't no hot tub time machine.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Get 1.1
Give 1.2, 1.3

Pretty fair if it's superflex or 2QB

[SurgeRUs]

Immediately after the Patriots drafted Damien Harris I received this gem:

Give: OBJ

Receive: Michel, 2.05

Was told my values on players are the worst ever when I told him that this offer was not close for OBJ.

[SaintSarcasticus]

Superflex league:

Give: K. Cousins, 2019 1.02

Receive: 2019 2.04, 2019 4.04, 2020 3rd

[FuzzySignificance]

someone literally just offered me a 2020 2nd for my 1.02

[myndflyte]

Finally got another offer to add to this thread.

In a superflex
Give: Joe Mixon
Get: 2019 3.08 and 2019 5.08

Based on that, if I offered my 2.05 and 4.05, I should be able to get Gurley. Edit: He declined my offer.

[HSCTiger]

I just got three ridiculous offers. I updated my trade bait today and got the following three offers in a 14-team Superflex:

Give: Todd Gurley

Get:
Brock Osweiler
Kareem Hunt
Jordan Wilkins
Year 2019 Draft Pick 4.05

AND

Give: Allen Robinson & Josh Allen

Get: Osweiler, Hunt, and Wilkins

AND

Give: Allen Robinson & 2019 Pick 1.10

Get: Osweiler, Hunt, and Wilkins.

I don't even know what to make of it. Does this guy think I'm epically stupid, a secret Osweiler truther, unaware that Hunt is with the Browns now, or is he just trolling me for no reason?

[TB3falcons]

Get: Trey Burton, Denzel Ward, and 2.04

Give: 1.01

Usually don't send snarky replies when I decline trades, but I couldn't resist...

[ArrylT]

Sometimes I feel like Rookie draft season is similar to a full moon - brings out really awful / weird offers

Offered: A. Ekeler for Jav Allen & 3.10

was rejected and counter was

A. Ekeler & 2020 1st for Jav Allen and 3.10

Made me rofl

[Flgatorguy87]

This was offered to me after I expressed interest in Lockett while the 1.06 team was about to be on the clock.

Tyler Lockett

for

1.08, 2020 2nd, Josh Rosen (this is a SF league and he had already been moved to Miami)

[bjd5211]

Give: 1.01, 1.08

Receive: Golladay, Agholor, 3.06

[FantasyFreak]

Just got posted in public on the Groupme:

Edelman, TY Hilton

for

David Johnson and 1.10

[ChefHerbie]

Got this killer offer the day before our rookie draft:

Get: 1.01, 3.01, 3.10
Give: OBJ and 2.02

[Jigga94]

Give: 1.01, 1.08

Receive: Golladay, Agholor, 3.06

Golladay > 1.01

That's not THAT bad of an offer

[bjd5211]

Give: 1.01, 1.08

Receive: Golladay, Agholor, 3.06

Golladay > 1.01

That's not THAT bad of an offer

Golladay is = 1.01 and Mizelle's ADP data backs this up, Golladay is currently going 1 spot ahead of Jacobs, by time the season starts though I expect Jacobs to overtake him. Now sure everyone is going to have their own preferences and rankings and there's not going to be a consensus on player values and rankings, but ADP data is the best way to know how the community at large values specific players. So if your opinion is that Golladay > 1.01 it's understandable, but I disagree, although I don't think the difference is very big in either direction.

Agholor + 3.06 for 1.08 however is not remotely close, and much greater than the difference between Golladay and 1.01 even if I did agree with your statement of Golladay > 1.01.

But to each their own.