2019 Off-Season Trade Thread

[TheNuts]

I gave 2020 1st and Royce Freeman

I got 1.05 (Kyler)

[FiremanEd]

I gave 2020 1st and Royce Freeman

I got 1.05 (Kyler)

I hope this is a SF...though question it since Kyler was still available at 1.05. If not, I'm not a big fan of the deal.

[Cult of Dionysus]

I gave 2020 1st and Royce Freeman

I got 1.05 (Kyler)

This makes little sense whether as a SF (where Murray shouldn't be available at @.05) or as a 1QB where that would be too rich for Murray. I sure hope your team is stacked so you didn't give away a top 6 pick in a loaded draft.

[TheNuts]

I gave 2020 1st and Royce Freeman

I got 1.05 (Kyler)

This makes little sense whether as a SF (where Murray shouldn't be available at @.05) or as a 1QB where that would be too rich for Murray. I sure hope your team is stacked so you didn't give away a top 6 pick in a loaded draft.

My team is good. It's not the best team in the league. I would say top 3 for sure

It's not a SF.

The last 4 years I finished 1st, 1st, 5th, 2nd.

I know I'm in the minority on Murray, but what if he ends up like Mahomes? Would you trade that for Mahomes?

[jenkins.math]

I gave 2020 1st and Royce Freeman

I got 1.05 (Kyler)

This makes little sense whether as a SF (where Murray shouldn't be available at @.05) or as a 1QB where that would be too rich for Murray. I sure hope your team is stacked so you didn't give away a top 6 pick in a loaded draft.

My team is good. It's not the best team in the league. I would say top 3 for sure

It's not a SF.

The last 4 years I finished 1st, 1st, 5th, 2nd.

I know I'm in the minority on Murray, but what if he ends up like Mahomes? Would you trade that for Mahomes?

Not in 1 QB I wouldn't.

[TheNuts]

This makes little sense whether as a SF (where Murray shouldn't be available at @.05) or as a 1QB where that would be too rich for Murray. I sure hope your team is stacked so you didn't give away a top 6 pick in a loaded draft.

My team is good. It's not the best team in the league. I would say top 3 for sure

It's not a SF.

The last 4 years I finished 1st, 1st, 5th, 2nd.

I know I'm in the minority on Murray, but what if he ends up like Mahomes? Would you trade that for Mahomes?

Not in 1 QB I wouldn't.

OK then idk what to say. You wouldn't trade an unknown in next year, next year, and a rb who isn't the 1 on his own team for a qb who there 50 tds. Yeah idk how that logic makes any sense.

[Sriracha]

My team is good. It's not the best team in the league. I would say top 3 for sure

It's not a SF.

The last 4 years I finished 1st, 1st, 5th, 2nd.

I know I'm in the minority on Murray, but what if he ends up like Mahomes? Would you trade that for Mahomes?

Not in 1 QB I wouldn't.

OK then idk what to say. You wouldn't trade an unknown in next year, next year, and a rb who isn't the 1 on his own team for a qb who there 50 tds. Yeah idk how that logic makes any sense.

Unless that's a 14+ team, I'm with Jenkins, here.

Mahomes isn't going to average 50TDs a year. More likely he settles in the 30TD a season range, which puts him in the same realm as other QBs.

[jenkins.math]

My team is good. It's not the best team in the league. I would say top 3 for sure

It's not a SF.

The last 4 years I finished 1st, 1st, 5th, 2nd.

I know I'm in the minority on Murray, but what if he ends up like Mahomes? Would you trade that for Mahomes?

Not in 1 QB I wouldn't.

OK then idk what to say. You wouldn't trade an unknown in next year, next year, and a rb who isn't the 1 on his own team for a qb who there 50 tds. Yeah idk how that logic makes any sense.

Kyler Murray hasn't played a game. That's entirely different. Also, I'm willing to bet whatever you want that Mahomes doesn't hit 50 TDs this year. Anybody paying those prices and expecting that production are going to look foolish.

Mahomes can have 35 TDs this year and that would be an awesome season. But I still wouldnt trade Freeman and a 2020 first for that kind of production in 1 QB.

[TheNuts]

But IIIIFFFF he hits 50 tds, is it worth it for a qb?

[jenkins.math]

But IIIIFFFF he hits 50 tds, is it worth it for a qb?

He would have to do it more than once.

However, if that is your justification on making the trade: "Mahomes threw for 50 last season, so as long as Murray does that I won"..... Maybe it works out for you, but the odds are so far stacked against you it's crazy.

[silvernblack151]

12 team ppr

Give: AJG

Get: Mike Williams, Curtis samuel, 2020 3rd

[smallxl]

Latest: 12 team PPR

Gave: MVS and D Freeman
Got: Jaylen Samuels and cooper Kupp

[Jigga94]

12 Team 1PPR

A: AJ Green
B: Tyreek Hill

Great move for team B

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

My team is good. It's not the best team in the league. I would say top 3 for sure

It's not a SF.

The last 4 years I finished 1st, 1st, 5th, 2nd.

I know I'm in the minority on Murray, but what if he ends up like Mahomes? Would you trade that for Mahomes?

Not in 1 QB I wouldn't.

OK then idk what to say. You wouldn't trade an unknown in next year, next year, and a rb who isn't the 1 on his own team for a qb who there 50 tds. Yeah idk how that logic makes any sense.

I'm with Jenkins. QB is just too deep with cheap high scoring options to give that for Mahomes, much less for Murray. I'm a Murray fan boy, but I think you overpaid by a 2020 1st.

Nothing wrong with overpaying to get your guy sometimes, though.

[TheNuts]

Not in 1 QB I wouldn't.

OK then idk what to say. You wouldn't trade an unknown in next year, next year, and a rb who isn't the 1 on his own team for a qb who there 50 tds. Yeah idk how that logic makes any sense.

I'm with Jenkins. QB is just too deep with cheap high scoring options to give that for Mahomes, much less for Murray. I'm a Murray fan boy, but I think you overpaid by a 2020 1st.

Nothing wrong with overpaying to get your guy sometimes, though.

Mahomes averaged 4 ppg more than the second best qb in the league. Gurley averaged 2 ppg over the second best rb. I get wanting running backs, but having a better ppg advantage is worth a deal no matter what position it is imo.