Robby Anderson 2018 Outlook

[Kelldon]

What do you think about Robby Anderson going forward? Is he a hold or a trade? If a trade what is he worth?

[FiremanEd]

I think if you’re going to sell the time is when the Jets get their next QB. Prior to then there will continue to be skepticism, which will remain for many even after that QB comes.

Given most wont give a 1st for him, I feel he is a hold, unless someone you like is on the board come Draft time in the second round. There is risk with Robby, but there is with the rookies as well. Robby has shown well the past 1.5 seasons on questionable teams. He’s not special, but he’s solid and developing.

Ultimately it depends on what price you can get for him.

[gunzwil guinea pigs]

Jets draft a QB.
Anderson is a Sell.
ASJ a Buy.

[koalabear]

Not selling him for a 2nd but won't be able to get a 1st for him. Therefore he's a hold for me.

Potentially he's one of those players to package up with others if you really want to get rid of him. Anderson and mid to late first for JuJu?

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Anderson and mid to late first for JuJu?

Good luck with that...no way any JuJu owner sells him for that.

[BigJoeWall72]

Not selling him for a 2nd but won't be able to get a 1st for him. Therefore he's a hold for me.

This is probably what most people will find if they put him on the block. He's probably worth it, but I'd be somewhat surprised if anyone would give a 1st for him. A 2nd definitely wouldn't be enough to get him from me if I still had him.

I'm mostly sure that holding him is a good thing though. He played solid enough at the end of 2016 as a UDFA with Bryce Petty, then follows that up with a WR1 season in 2017 while McCown was playing (11th in PPR scoring through 13 weeks). If the Jets sign or draft a talented QB, I see no reason he won't put up at least WR2 numbers in year 3, especially with the coaching staff remaining in place for the NYJ.

[Mjvb5]

Worth a mid-late first but no one is gonna give that IMO so I’ll hold

[cazzie33]

Worth a mid-late first but no one is gonna give that IMO so I’ll hold

Same here...definitely would have him the Ridley range if he was in draft. But probably won't bring back that in trade even though he's a proven commodity.

[dynastyninja]

Worth a mid-late first but no one is gonna give that IMO so I’ll hold

No way he's worth a mid first. At best he's a late first. I believe in the guy, but I'm not even confident in 1st round value for him.

[hockeyBjj]

In talks with one guy for my Robby for the 1.9

and also Robby and 18 2nd for early (as much as a guaranteed top 3 as anything can be a year away, his team defines dumpster fire) 19 1st

He's my WR4, behind OBJ, Evans, and Landry, with me with JuJu and Corey Davis as much higher upside bench/bye WRs

Hoping the guy pulls the trigger. Poor timing as comish just pulled his trading rights until he cuts two players as he hasn't activated his IR guys yet

[TheChicken]

Last off-season I acquired A Theilen & M Lee for a mid 2nd and late 2nd respectively .... Which is where I think trades involving Robby Anderson will sit. Obviously I thought I was winning both those trades at the time and in the league I own Anderson I will not be selling at those prices .... But I think you will struggle to find suitors at higher prices.

[Lotto4Life]

I sold Anderson and Kupp for Cousins before Week 10. (My QB situation was maddening at the time and Cousins carried me for a couple of weeks.) Not sure if you can glean anything from that.

[koalabear]

Anderson and mid to late first for JuJu?

Good luck with that...no way any JuJu owner sells him for that.

Haha you're right. I also own JuJu and was offered just the 1.10 for him. Er....pass!

[kris_kapsner]

I paid a 1st in 2019 for Anderson.

My team has been among the top 3-4 teams basically every year. So, I'm banking that I gave a pick in the 12-16 range for him and am happy with that...especially since Fitz won't keep going forever and I'll probably lose him this off season with all the retiring going on there.

[Shcritters]

It’s going to be interesting when Enunwa comes back. Quincy was supposed to be the breakout this year and is built more like a prototypical WR1 because of his size/weight. The range of outcomes is Quincy coming back and relegating Anderson to a ‘deep threat’ role to having no impact and Enunwa still being the WR to own.