DE or S which side do you like? POLL

General discussion and team advice concerning IDP Leagues.

WHich would you rather have?

JPP
9
56%
Harrison Smith
7
44%
 
Total votes: 16

User avatar
deadpool
Role Player
Role Player
Posts: 399
Joined: Mon May 20, 2013 5:27 pm

DE or S which side do you like? POLL

Postby deadpool » Sun Jun 21, 2015 6:49 pm

We are in the middle of our Free Agent Draft and I have an offer on the table for Harrison Smith for my JPP

If I trade JPP, I still have JJ Watt and Ziggy. I don't have any Safeties yet but they are all available but 2. What should I do?

we use 2/2/2/Flex for IDP roster
Our scoring is
3pts for Sacks
1pt for Tackles
.5pt for Assists
1pt Passes Defensed
3pts INT
4pts Safeties
2pts Forced Fumbles

10 Teams nonPPR $1200 Sal/Contract 40man roster
P/R TD 4 - Rush TD 6
1QB/1RB/1WR/1TE/3Flex/1PK/2DTDE,2LB,2SCB,1DFlex

2017 Roster w/contracts so far
QBs : Cam $89/1, Winston $45/2, Bridgewater $10/4, Kap $1/3
RBs : Gurley $50/2, Gordon $45/3, Sims $20/2, McKinnon $5/1
WRs : M. Evans $40/1, A. Robinson $10/1, Diggs $43/3, DeVante Parker $30/4, Moncrief $10/1, Kelvin Benjamin $40/1, Malcolm Mitchell $5/4
TEs : Ertz $30/3, Eric Ebron $30/1
DEs : JJ Watt $30/1, Ezekiel Ansah $24/3, Khalil Mack $10/2,Danielle Hunter $1/3, JPP $1/2
LBs : Bowman $8/1, S.Lee $1/1, J Hicks $14/3, Clowney $5/1
DBs : Geathers $1/3

2017 Pix 1.04, 1.05
2018 Pix 3 1st,1 3rd,3 4th

User avatar
Chocolate Droppa
Practice Squad
Practice Squad
Posts: 137
Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2015 12:05 am

Re: DE or S which side do you like? POLL

Postby Chocolate Droppa » Sun Jun 21, 2015 6:57 pm

With only 1 point per tackle I voted JPP. There are fewer elite DEs than DBs in the league. Especially since all but 2 are still available. Once you get past Watt, Quinn, Jones, and JPP, the talent level drops dramatically.

User avatar
Seb49ers
Practice Squad
Practice Squad
Posts: 177
Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2015 3:18 am
Location: France
Contact:

Re: DE or S which side do you like? POLL

Postby Seb49ers » Mon Jun 22, 2015 4:53 am

JPP by a big margin for me.

More Elite DB than elite DE like Chocolate Droppa said and far more difference between a TOP 5 / Top 20 DE than between Top 5 / Top 20 DB.
https://twitter.com/SebZehoual

Listen (or don't) to me, I'm so good/average/bad :
Main Dynasty with Friends (a lot of pride involved) 10 Team 2QB-2TE + IDP : 5-3 (2nd 2016, 3rd 2015-2017)
Dynasty 12 Team 2QB-2TE + IDP : 7-1 (2nd 2015, first round PO 2016, 4th 2017)
Dynasty 12 Team Salary Cap and Contract, SFlex + Devy : 5-3 (Rebuild since 2015, still no PO)
Dynasty 12 Team Salary Cap and Contract, SFlex : 6-2 (Winner 2017, 2nd 2016, no PO in 2015)
Dynasty 14 Team, SFlex + IDP : 11-5 (4th 2017, No PO 2016, 2015)
Dynasty 80 Team (5 * 16), SFlex + IDP : 7-9 (New League)
Dynasty 12 Team, 2Sflex + IDP : 4-4 (New League)

User avatar
deadpool
Role Player
Role Player
Posts: 399
Joined: Mon May 20, 2013 5:27 pm

Re: DE or S which side do you like? POLL

Postby deadpool » Mon Jun 22, 2015 6:12 am

Thanks guys! I declined the deal. I figured I should, I just wanted to confirm my thoughts by getting other opinions!

10 Teams nonPPR $1200 Sal/Contract 40man roster
P/R TD 4 - Rush TD 6
1QB/1RB/1WR/1TE/3Flex/1PK/2DTDE,2LB,2SCB,1DFlex

2017 Roster w/contracts so far
QBs : Cam $89/1, Winston $45/2, Bridgewater $10/4, Kap $1/3
RBs : Gurley $50/2, Gordon $45/3, Sims $20/2, McKinnon $5/1
WRs : M. Evans $40/1, A. Robinson $10/1, Diggs $43/3, DeVante Parker $30/4, Moncrief $10/1, Kelvin Benjamin $40/1, Malcolm Mitchell $5/4
TEs : Ertz $30/3, Eric Ebron $30/1
DEs : JJ Watt $30/1, Ezekiel Ansah $24/3, Khalil Mack $10/2,Danielle Hunter $1/3, JPP $1/2
LBs : Bowman $8/1, S.Lee $1/1, J Hicks $14/3, Clowney $5/1
DBs : Geathers $1/3

2017 Pix 1.04, 1.05
2018 Pix 3 1st,1 3rd,3 4th


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 28 guests