Dynasty League Football Forum

What’s the gap between Chubb and Gordon in keeper/dynasty leagues at the moment? Is there even a gap in half ppr anymore? Yeah Gordon has the edge as a receiver for sure but does Chubb’s superior rushing ability, lesser injury history in the NFL, not fully tapped receiving potential and the fact tha...

Easily Goodwin for me. Near identical situations (WR2s on good offenses behind a stud WR1) and similar talent levels, but Godwin doesn’t have Fuller’s injury history.

What about Chubb and Guice? Does that swing it too much in the other direction? Or would you still take Gordon? Yeah I’d take Guice and Chubb for Gordon, both younger potential RB1s and the gap between Chubb and Gordon isn’t that big anymore. The fact that you were contemplating Royce and Guice for...

I LOVE Guice and while I acquired both Chubb and Guice this past season, Guice was my first target. I only got Chubb as a throw-in for Mahomes prior to the Carlos Hyde trade. That said, Chubb looks like a total stud since taking over. That offer is too light for Chubb. As much as I love Guice, I thi...

I don't know... we're looking at a player who has appeared in 12 games each of his first two seasons.... will he ever play a full season?... Plus, Jamal Williams usually fills in quite well... and was an earlier draft pick. that said, I think Sterling Shepard is just a guy, and a mid 1st round pick...

The value is on the Hunt side but like most have said, it probably makes the most sense for your team to keep Allen. Is it though? The way I see it is that this trade is the equivalent of two early seconds and a mid-first. I’d imagine KA’s value is at least that of two early firsts in a non-loaded ...

**UPDATE** He countered. Give: Tyler Boyd Get: Aaron Jones I feel like the value is fair but I also feel Boyd is much more of a sure thing.....especially longer term. Talk me into it!! Like you said exactly. If you’re looking to win now, I’d take the Jones side. If you’re looking to build a better ...

Z$$$ wrote: ↑Tue Jan 29, 2019 10:35 am Curious what everyone thought the gap was.

Thanks!

The gap is HUGE. I’d imagine two 2019 firsts or a less proven but high upside RB like Kerryon Guice or Fournette. I know 2 firsts > Guice/Fournette/Kerryon but no way I’d sell Chubb for just Kupp and a single first in next year’s class.

The fact that you have Kittle gives Golladay a significant edge here. I’d def keep him over Henry in this scenario.

Cooks is clearly the best player in this deal but I think I’d take the Golladay/Henry side. I’d imagine we’re going to get at least what we got last year from Golladay every year going forward, but his ceiling is a stud top 5 WR. Yeah, Golladay was only a low-end WR2 compared to Cooks being a high-e...

Yeah I’d 100% keep Allen here. Hunt, Kirk and the 1.05 are all way too uncertain to gamble away a surefire top 10 WR in his prime.

Give me Kamara here mainly because I think he’s less dependent on his surrounding situation than Thomas, and given Brees’s days are numbered, I think situation will end up being the difference between them.

Not a fan of Fuller because I hate inconsistency/injuries. Guy’s undoubtedly talented but I doubt he ever reaches his true potential considering he gets injured every single year. That said, if you’re fine with having a high-end WR2/low-end WR1 for 4-6 games a year who’s proly useless after those g...

Not a fan of Fuller because I hate inconsistency/injuries. Guy’s undoubtedly talented but I doubt he ever reaches his true potential considering he gets injured every single year. That said, if you’re fine with having a high-end WR2/low-end WR1 for 4-6 games a year who’s proly useless after those ga...

Agree with what everyone has said. Difference between Zeke and Barkley is proly a second round pick, not Guice. Saquon is only slightly better than Zeke (albeit younger) but Guice has RB1 upside. Not sure I’d do that deal for Saquon. Odell trade is a steal though.