Pick one RB to keep

[Shoebox]

I have a few options and it is way too early to make a decision but I thought I would throw out the question.

Who of these RB's would you keep and why (pick one):

Mark Ingram
Rashard Mendenhall
Lamar Miller
Ben Tate
Ryan Williams

Or, if you prefer, rank them in order.

[Team Tacos]

Lamar Miller
Ryan Williams
Ben Tate
Mendenhall
Ingram

[Swids19]

I like Lamar Miller becuase out of all your options, he;s the best RB in line to win the #1 RB role with his team (unless R. Bush resigns with Miami). I plan on keeping Miller as one of my 6 keeper in my team #2 signature. Good luck.

[meineymoe]

I would not keep Mendenhall, Tate, or probably even Ryan Williams because of his injuries.

So, between Lamar Miller and Mark Ingram - I like both of their fortunes and think their best years are ahead of them. Miller right now is the sexy choice, but I think Ingram has been showing some progress, especially towards the end of this past season, and think he will have a solid role in that offense going forward.

By August or whenever you have to make this choice, it might be a little clearer choice, but I bet it comes down to these two.

-oo-

[burnonedown]

Lamar Miller
Mendenhall
Ryan Williams
Ingram
Ben Tate


Id keep Miller, i like his chances and situation.

[jwb53]

If Reggie Bush leaves Miami, I'd keep Miller.

[Shoebox]

If Reggie Bush leaves Miami, I'd keep Miller.

And if Reggie stays?

[meineymoe]

If Reggie Bush leaves Miami, I'd keep Miller.

And if Reggie stays?

Maybe wait and resurrect this thread later in the summer since you don't have to make a decision right now.

-oo-

[Kisasi]

Mark Ingram
Ben Tate
Lamar Miller
Ryan Williams
Rashard Mendenhall

[jwb53]

If Reggie Bush leaves Miami, I'd keep Miller.

And if Reggie stays?

Mark Ingram

[MilwaukeesBest]

If Reggie Bush leaves Miami, I'd keep Miller.

Agreed. Looks like Bush is on his way out, but only time will tell.

[will6779]

miller then ingram but its close.