Which lineup would you rather have? KEEPER LG

[danb22]

12 man league, keep one player. No-PPR. Start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 Flex, 1 TE. 4 pt passing TD, 6 pt TD otherwise

Rodgers
Mathews
SJax
Julio Jones
Antonio Brown
Reggie Wayne
Gates
Bench: Battle, D.Richardson, Witten, TBMW, Simpson, Vincent Brown, Luck

or

Rivers
McCoy
Mathews
Julio Jones
Antonio Brown
Reggie Wayne
Gates
Bench: SJax, Battle, D.Richardson, Witten, TBMW, Vincent Brown, Luck


As you may see, I am after Rodgers but believe I will have to give up Shady in the process. The other guy really needs a RB (his RB1 is Donald Brown) and basically demands Shady be involved. I'm a cheesehead so the idea of keeping Rodgers year over year is really tempting....but losing a top 3 RB like McCoy would hurt.

Thoughts?