Dynasty Superflex 1.01 - Does it have to be Caleb Williams?

[Lehigh98]

It looks like Superflex Tier 1 has come down to Caleb Williams and Marvin Harrison Jr and we know that in Superflex leagues, QB's are king. Caleb Williams has been in the lead for 1.01 for quite some time and now steps into a much better situation with the Bears than the 1.01 normally would. We're also hearing the word "generational" getting thrown around for MHJ and he ends up in a good situation and should get a great target share right away.

Every post-draft Superflex mock I've seen has Caleb Williams at the 1.01, is this the correct call or take-lock? Is Caleb Williams the automatic pick at 1.01? Are there any situations where you would consider going with MHJ at the 1.01 instead?

How do YOU go about evaluating the decision? Best trade value? Best for your team? Least risk? Other factors?

[Mtt33]

Caleb tier 1 all alone for me in a typical 12+ team Superflex. Very deep starting positions or weird scoring could change that I suppose.

[Buckhill Bombers]

Although I love MHjr I do feel like you almost have to take Caleb Williams at 1.1 in a SF, but if you just don't need a QB I'd look into trading back for more assets.

[Viking386]

MHJ has gone first in 4 of the 6 rookie drafts I have done so far. The MHJ is hype is real

[abloom]

12+ team SF give me Caleb

10team SF give me MHJ

Best ball SF 12 or 14 team I think MHJ, 16+ probably caleb

[CGW]

I've tried to convince myself many times to take MHJ over Williams in SF, but I just can't do it. All my leagues are 12+ teams and QBs carry crazy value. It's going to be really hard for CW to fail, despite everyone saying he's already a bust because he paints his fingernails and cries when he loses. (You wanna see an actual grown man cry, watch the Lakers tonight - I'd say LeBron has done just fine despite being overly dramatic, arrogant, and generally unlikeable)

[knotts4372]

if it comes down to me needing qb and being stacked at wr, im still not taking caleb until i shop the pick. make it clear im looking for a good qb plus in return and see what offers i get. some teams might be rebuilding but have a guy like hurts or herbert who arent old by any means but getting a guy thats a few yrs younger might appeal to them

[TheTroll]

12+ team SF give me Caleb

10team SF give me MHJ

Best ball SF 12 or 14 team I think MHJ, 16+ probably caleb

^^^^ this