Page 1 of 6

Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 9:58 am
by Jrblaha
And go…

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 10:08 am
by Cameron Giles
Posted this in the other thread:

1.01: Harrison Jr.
1.02: Nabers
1.03: Odunze
1.04: Bowers
1.05: Worthy
1.06: McConkey
1.07: Coleman
1.08: Thomas Jr.
1.09: Pearsall
1.10: Brooks
1.11: C. Williams
1.12: Mitchell

Next 4: Benson, Daniels, Polk, Legette

Picks after 1.04 will be interesting. I would argue that there's not much of a difference between 1.05-1.12 quality wise.

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 10:33 am
by Lumps
Feels like Brooks and/or Benson should be higher. I understand why not, but also there’s plenty of WRs. I think we will see them much higher.

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 11:18 am
by dmoyer121099
Lumps wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 10:33 am Feels like Brooks and/or Benson should be higher. I understand why not, but also there’s plenty of WRs. I think we will see them much higher.
X2 There will certainly be someone in every league that pursues rb early.
Imo though…

1.01 MHJ
1.02 Nabers
1.03 Odunze
1.04 Bowers
1.05 Thomas Jr.
1.06 Brooks
1.07 Caleb
1.08 Ladd
1.09 Worthy
1.10 Keon
1.11 Benson
1.12 Legette

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 11:49 am
by Bronco Billy
This is where I’d put them (assuming ppr no TEP)

1.01 MHJ
1.02 Odunze
1.03 Nabers
1.04 BTJ
1.05 McConkey
1.06 Benson
1.07 Bowers
1.08 Pearsall
1.09 Williams
1.10 Brooks
1.11 Polk
1.12 Burton

No way I’m burning a 1st rounder on Worthy, Legette or Coleman. Some of these WRs are going to bust and I see all 3 of them as prime candidates. I’d rather risk Burton getting mature enough to resolve his anger/attitude enough to realize his pro potential than rely on fixing the holes in those 3’s games.

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 12:06 pm
by tstafford
Bronco Billy wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 11:49 am This is where I’d put them (assuming ppr no TEP)

1.01 MHJ
1.02 Odunze
1.03 Nabers
1.04 BTJ
1.05 McConkey
1.06 Benson
1.07 Bowers
1.08 Pearsall
1.09 Williams
1.10 Brooks
1.11 Polk
1.12 Burton

No way I’m burning a 1st rounder on Worthy, Legette or Coleman. Some of these WRs are going to bust and I see all 3 of them as prime candidates. I’d rather risk Burton getting mature enough to resolve his anger/attitude enough to realize his pro potential than rely on fixing the holes in those 3’s games.
I tend to agree w/ you on all three WRs. Rice remains the best option when on the field in KCC.

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 12:56 pm
by jordanzs
I could see brooks and benson going early though. An owner with a 1.5 pick who also has a 2.5 pick will figure out that they can get a quality receiver at 2.5. So if their goal is to add a RB and a WR in the first 2 rounds, that might be the play.

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 1:08 pm
by BHSU
In TEP full point, is Bowers 1.4

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 2:18 pm
by YouMightDieTryin
1.01: Harrison Jr.
1.02: Nabers
1.03: Odunze
1.04: McConkey
1.05: Worthy
1.06: Thomas Jr
1.07: Bowers
1.08: Coleman
1.09: C. Williams
1.10: Brooks
1.11: Pearsall
1.12: Mitchell

Non TEprem pushes the desire to draft Bowers down for me. But at some point his upside is just greater than any WR. He could even be 1.5 over Worthy.

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 3:50 pm
by spotxc
Jrblaha wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 9:58 amAnd go…
No go

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 4:30 pm
by natjjohn
Bronco Billy wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 11:49 am This is where I’d put them (assuming ppr no TEP)

1.01 MHJ
1.02 Odunze
1.03 Nabers
1.04 BTJ
1.05 McConkey
1.06 Benson
1.07 Bowers
1.08 Pearsall
1.09 Williams
1.10 Brooks
1.11 Polk
1.12 Burton

No way I’m burning a 1st rounder on Worthy, Legette or Coleman. Some of these WRs are going to bust and I see all 3 of them as prime candidates. I’d rather risk Burton getting mature enough to resolve his anger/attitude enough to realize his pro potential than rely on fixing the holes in those 3’s games.
I see the logic but I think Worthy is drafted aggressively for sure. Chiefs, offense , first round pick, imagine hype train will continue to grow. Expect him to being going third or 4th by June

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 5:37 pm
by Bronco Billy
natjjohn wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 4:30 pm
Bronco Billy wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 11:49 am This is where I’d put them (assuming ppr no TEP)

1.01 MHJ
1.02 Odunze
1.03 Nabers
1.04 BTJ
1.05 McConkey
1.06 Benson
1.07 Bowers
1.08 Pearsall
1.09 Williams
1.10 Brooks
1.11 Polk
1.12 Burton

No way I’m burning a 1st rounder on Worthy, Legette or Coleman. Some of these WRs are going to bust and I see all 3 of them as prime candidates. I’d rather risk Burton getting mature enough to resolve his anger/attitude enough to realize his pro potential than rely on fixing the holes in those 3’s games.
I see the logic but I think Worthy is drafted aggressively for sure. Chiefs, offense , first round pick, imagine hype train will continue to grow. Expect him to being going third or 4th by June
How is Reid’s history on evaluating WRs to draft on day 1 or day 2?

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 5:56 pm
by YouMightDieTryin
Bronco Billy wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 5:37 pm
natjjohn wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 4:30 pm
Bronco Billy wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 11:49 am This is where I’d put them (assuming ppr no TEP)

1.01 MHJ
1.02 Odunze
1.03 Nabers
1.04 BTJ
1.05 McConkey
1.06 Benson
1.07 Bowers
1.08 Pearsall
1.09 Williams
1.10 Brooks
1.11 Polk
1.12 Burton

No way I’m burning a 1st rounder on Worthy, Legette or Coleman. Some of these WRs are going to bust and I see all 3 of them as prime candidates. I’d rather risk Burton getting mature enough to resolve his anger/attitude enough to realize his pro potential than rely on fixing the holes in those 3’s games.
I see the logic but I think Worthy is drafted aggressively for sure. Chiefs, offense , first round pick, imagine hype train will continue to grow. Expect him to being going third or 4th by June
How is Reid’s history on evaluating WRs to draft on day 1 or day 2?
As most of said this isn't doesn't have to be our personal rankings, but how we foresee drafts happening. Given my current rankings/picks I'm hoping others take Worthy/Coleman before me so I don't have to. If they we both to be available at the end of the 1st then that makes a smaller conundrum that I'll end up taking whoever had the better DC (assuming I'll be stuck with the pick).

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 6:07 pm
by Mike11
YouMightDieTryin wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 5:56 pm
Bronco Billy wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 5:37 pm
natjjohn wrote: Sun Apr 28, 2024 4:30 pm

I see the logic but I think Worthy is drafted aggressively for sure. Chiefs, offense , first round pick, imagine hype train will continue to grow. Expect him to being going third or 4th by June
How is Reid’s history on evaluating WRs to draft on day 1 or day 2?
As most of said this isn't doesn't have to be our personal rankings, but how we foresee drafts happening. Given my current rankings/picks I'm hoping others take Worthy/Coleman before me so I don't have to. If they we both to be available at the end of the 1st then that makes a smaller conundrum that I'll end up taking whoever had the better DC (assuming I'll be stuck with the pick).
Going Worthy over BTJ is what I’m seeing a lot dynasty twitter saying and I don’t see it. Thomas is clearly at worst the second target on his team with better draft capital and a solid QB and a clear X role. Worthy feels right after BTJ but seeing Worthy get gassed up I’m not there personally.

Re: Post Draft top 12 1 QB

Posted: Sun Apr 28, 2024 6:11 pm
by Cameron Giles
Yeah, I don't see any way that Worthy is not a 1st rounder in rookie drafts, though it wasn't really clear if these are our own rankings or how we think drafts will go.

KC has been sketchy with evaluating WR talent though outside of Rice. Worthy is very different though from what they usually pick.