Is Devon Achane’s value low right now?

[kmbryant09]

I regularly see Wilson ahead of Puka and AJB, I don't think he should be over either. I also have Nabers over Wilson.
I could also make cases for Aiyuk, Tyreek, Waddle, Higgins, and maybe even Olave over Wilson if we are actually counting production.
I also have Waddle, Higgins and London above GW/Olave.

I mean Olave has averaged 13.85 PPR PPG through his first 2 seasons, and GW has averaged 12.6 PPR PPG through his first 2 seasons.
Dudes like Waddle, 15.3 PPR PPG though his first 2 seasons, Higgins, 14.3 though his first 2 seasons, are behind Olave and GW, seemingly only because they did not attend Ohio State.

Did you attend Michigan? Or got rejected by Ohio State? I don't really understand your logic other than the Ohio State angle - it seems to be 10x more important to you than quality of targets, QB play, offensive ineptitude, draft capital, etc.

[MacDaddy123]

I regularly see Wilson ahead of Puka and AJB, I don't think he should be over either. I also have Nabers over Wilson.
I could also make cases for Aiyuk, Tyreek, Waddle, Higgins, and maybe even Olave over Wilson if we are actually counting production.
I also have Waddle, Higgins and London above GW/Olave.

I mean Olave has averaged 13.85 PPR PPG through his first 2 seasons, and GW has averaged 12.6 PPR PPG through his first 2 seasons.
Dudes like Waddle, 15.3 PPR PPG though his first 2 seasons, Higgins, 14.3 though his first 2 seasons, are behind Olave and GW, seemingly only because they did not attend Ohio State.

Did you attend Michigan? Or got rejected by Ohio State? I don't really understand your logic other than the Ohio State angle - it seems to be 10x more important to you than quality of targets, QB play, offensive ineptitude, draft capital, etc.

No, not at all.
many dynasty players are over-valued, and many are under-valued.
I'm just trying to understand why Wilson, Olave, and JSN are all over-rated.
Maybe you have a better explanation. Maybe it is a coincidence that all 3 went to the same school.

JSN has a VERY bad year, yet excuses are flowing freely everywhere.

Facts are that here is a list of WR's who got 1st round NFL Draft capital, then went on to score fewer than 9 PPR PPG in their rookie season:

Jaxon Smith-Njigba
Quentin Johnston

Treylon Burks
Jameson Williams

Rashod Bateman

Henry Ruggs
Jalen Reagor

N'Keal Harry

Corey Davis
Mike Williams
John Ross

Will Fuller V
Josh Doctson
Laquon Treadwell

Kevin White
DeVante Parker
Nelson Agholor
Breshad Perriman
Phillip Dorsett

Here are some players that scored over 9 points as a rookie, so they couldn't make the list:

Kadarious Toney
Kelvin Benjamin
Corey Coleman


Now only 1 player on this list who's fantasy value has not taken a hit, despite historically poor performance.
Let's see if you can figure out who here is over-valued.

[CGW]

I regularly see Wilson ahead of Puka and AJB, I don't think he should be over either. I also have Nabers over Wilson.
I could also make cases for Aiyuk, Tyreek, Waddle, Higgins, and maybe even Olave over Wilson if we are actually counting production.
I also have Waddle, Higgins and London above GW/Olave.

I mean Olave has averaged 13.85 PPR PPG through his first 2 seasons, and GW has averaged 12.6 PPR PPG through his first 2 seasons.
Dudes like Waddle, 15.3 PPR PPG though his first 2 seasons, Higgins, 14.3 though his first 2 seasons, are behind Olave and GW, seemingly only because they did not attend Ohio State.

Did you attend Michigan? Or got rejected by Ohio State? I don't really understand your logic other than the Ohio State angle - it seems to be 10x more important to you than quality of targets, QB play, offensive ineptitude, draft capital, etc.

Lol now that's funny!

[TheTroll]

Achane is a stud with obvious potential injury

[tstafford]

Achane is a stud with obvious potential injury

Agreed. Feels like we have a few guys like this - Achane, Dell and AR come to mind. People are going to need to either gamble or sit out. I don't think any of them are going to come at much of a discount. Someone in most leagues will pay up. I've decided I'm in on all three. I love AR's upside in 1QB where finding a replacement is easier. Of the three Achane scares me the most - but I bought him in my SF league anyway.

[The.Big.Spank]

I think buying shrimpy running backs is too risky for me to give up premium draft capital. He might be worth it, but I would rather spend the value I would need to get him (which is currently a lot) on something less risky.