CJ Stroud & Coin Flips

[Anteaters]

[Anteaters]

Week 5 was another good performance for Stroud.

I know it's the most reactionary of sites, but can KTC actually have Stroud as dynasty QB6? And even FantasyPros has him up to QB10. Heavens to murgatroid!

[tstafford]

Week 5 was another good performance for Stroud.

I know it's the most reactionary of sites, but can KTC actually have Stroud as dynasty QB6? And even FantasyPros has him up to QB10. Heavens to murgatroid!

Yeah. Love Stroud, own Stroud. Not the QB6. Bridge too far.

[Jigga94]

QBs I would definitely take over Stroud
Mahomes, Allen, Hurts, Herbert

QBs I would probably take over Stroud
Lamar, Burrow, Trevor

QBs that I consider in the same tier, but would likely take Stroud
Richardson, Tua, Purdy

QB6 probably too high to say you would definitely take him over 2 of Lamar/Burrow/Trevor, but he's close. He's easily a top 10 dynasty QB. I didn't love him as a prospect either, but have quickly become a fan

[ButtFumbleCity]

Agree 6 is probably too have for him right now but if you watch any of the film studies on him you can see just how well he's processing the field which was supposedly a big weakness. Also he's more willing to run than he was in college, although that's still not saying too much.

[tstafford]

QBs I would definitely take over Stroud
Mahomes, Allen, Hurts, Herbert

QBs I would probably take over Stroud
Lamar, Burrow, Trevor

QBs that I consider in the same tier, but would likely take Stroud
Richardson, Tua, Purdy

QB6 probably too high to say you would definitely take him over 2 of Lamar/Burrow/Trevor, but he's close. He's easily a top 10 dynasty QB. I didn't love him as a prospect either, but have quickly become a fan

Mostly agree. Although I would move Tua up a tier. Richardson is tricky. I like him a lot and would prefer to own him to Stroud, however he's finished one out of four games he's started. That's worrisome.

[ButtFumbleCity]

QBs I would definitely take over Stroud
Mahomes, Allen, Hurts, Herbert

QBs I would probably take over Stroud
Lamar, Burrow, Trevor

QBs that I consider in the same tier, but would likely take Stroud
Richardson, Tua, Purdy

QB6 probably too high to say you would definitely take him over 2 of Lamar/Burrow/Trevor, but he's close. He's easily a top 10 dynasty QB. I didn't love him as a prospect either, but have quickly become a fan

Mostly agree. Although I would move Tua up a tier. Richardson is tricky. I like him a lot and would prefer to own him to Stroud, however he's finished one out of four games he's started. That's worrisome.

Ehhh give me the guy who's a good bet to play 15 seasons and not miss many games over someone who's already missed 80% of his games.

[ButtFumbleCity]

QBs I would definitely take over Stroud
Mahomes, Allen, Hurts, Herbert

QBs I would probably take over Stroud
Lamar, Burrow, Trevor

QBs that I consider in the same tier, but would likely take Stroud
Richardson, Tua, Purdy

QB6 probably too high to say you would definitely take him over 2 of Lamar/Burrow/Trevor, but he's close. He's easily a top 10 dynasty QB. I didn't love him as a prospect either, but have quickly become a fan

Mostly agree. Although I would move Tua up a tier. Richardson is tricky. I like him a lot and would prefer to own him to Stroud, however he's finished one out of four games he's started. That's worrisome.

Ehhh give me the guy who's a good bet to play 15 seasons and not miss many games over someone who's already in line to miss a bunch of games.

[tstafford]

QBs I would definitely take over Stroud
Mahomes, Allen, Hurts, Herbert

QBs I would probably take over Stroud
Lamar, Burrow, Trevor

QBs that I consider in the same tier, but would likely take Stroud
Richardson, Tua, Purdy

QB6 probably too high to say you would definitely take him over 2 of Lamar/Burrow/Trevor, but he's close. He's easily a top 10 dynasty QB. I didn't love him as a prospect either, but have quickly become a fan

Mostly agree. Although I would move Tua up a tier. Richardson is tricky. I like him a lot and would prefer to own him to Stroud, however he's finished one out of four games he's started. That's worrisome.

Ehhh give me the guy who's a good bet to play 15 seasons and not miss many games over someone who's already missed 80% of his games.

That's what I meant although I can see how it was misinterpreted. I want to own him but I couldn't at this point take him over Stroud given the injury risk. Wish it wasn't like that and it might be shortsighted to see it this way. Taking Stroud in 2QB for sure. Can take more risk in 1QB - at least most leagues.

[Jigga94]

QBs I would definitely take over Stroud
Mahomes, Allen, Hurts, Herbert

QBs I would probably take over Stroud
Lamar, Burrow, Trevor

QBs that I consider in the same tier, but would likely take Stroud
Richardson, Tua, Purdy

QB6 probably too high to say you would definitely take him over 2 of Lamar/Burrow/Trevor, but he's close. He's easily a top 10 dynasty QB. I didn't love him as a prospect either, but have quickly become a fan

Mostly agree. Although I would move Tua up a tier. Richardson is tricky. I like him a lot and would prefer to own him to Stroud, however he's finished one out of four games he's started. That's worrisome.

Kinda ironic that you worry about Richardson health and not Tua. Personally, that's the main reason I'd rank Stroud ahead of them. I think they have more upside (definitely Richardson with the rushing), but Stroud just seems like such a safe bet and should only continue to improve. Nico and Tank look good, but I'd love for him to have a true #1 or a better OL/run game to open up the offense more.

Edit: ahh I can see the difference. You're referring to 1QB where ceiling is paramount and I'm skewed towards SF, where a backend QB1 in your QB2 spot is a blessing

[zeeshan2]

So...how about that performance yesterday?

[Ice]

So...how about that performance yesterday?

ROY by a mile at this point.

Nice Rookie record of 470 with 5 TD's and no picks. That record should hold up for years.

[ButtFumbleCity]

So...how about that performance yesterday?

ROY by a mile at this point.

Nice Rookie record of 470 with 5 TD's and no picks. That record should hold up for years.

Unless he beats it himself in the next 9 games.

[Jigga94]

QBs I would definitely take over Stroud
Mahomes, Allen, Hurts, Herbert

QBs I would probably take over Stroud
Lamar, Burrow, Trevor

QBs that I consider in the same tier, but would likely take Stroud
Richardson, Tua, Purdy

QB6 probably too high to say you would definitely take him over 2 of Lamar/Burrow/Trevor, but he's close. He's easily a top 10 dynasty QB. I didn't love him as a prospect either, but have quickly become a fan

QBs I would definitely take over Stroud
Mahomes, Allen, Hurts

QBs I would probably take over Stroud
Herbert

QBs that I consider in the same tier, but would likely take Stroud
Lamar, Burrow, Trevor

[Anteaters]

So...how about that performance yesterday?

ROY by a mile at this point.

Nice Rookie record of 470 with 5 TD's and no picks. That record should hold up for years.

Unless he beats it himself in the next 9 games.

That's very very possible.