Dynasty League Football Forum

So, who do you like better and why? I'm seeing ADP on these three being pretty close. Assume 12-man, 1 ppr, 1 qb leagues.

Mingo ADP 24 6'2" CAR (drafted 39th) rated 6.27
Tillman ADP 25 6'3" CLE (drafted 74th) rated 6.38
JReed ADP 29 5'1'' GBP (drafted 50th) rated 5.98

Youll have to make this choice in the mid/late 2nd. Not an easy one. Mingo has the most mystery and also easiest path to points. Hate it, but I'd go with him over the other two.

Mingo my third rated wr in draft. Tillman fourth. Reed around 10th. I think Tillman and Mingo severely underrated.

lic217 wrote: ↑Tue May 02, 2023 3:28 am Mingo my third rated wr in draft. Tillman fourth. Reed around 10th. I think Tillman and Mingo severely underrated.

Can we see your 2023 Top 10 WR rankings out of interest?

Reed is one of the best values in the draft. I have him, then Mingo, then a noticeable break....then Tillman.

Have Mingo and Reed very close as of now. Thought both got better DC than anticipated, especially Reed (thought hed be a deep sleeper). They are in the tier right behind the 1st round WR so WR5/6 for me.

Tillman kind of the opposite. Expected a little better capital. Landing spot isn't terrible, but I don't see him making a big impact this year. Dropped him to the next tier of guys behind Rashee, Mims, and Downs.

I’m definitely not a Mingo fan. Of Reed and Tillman, I’ll go with Reed because I think he has more ways to win on routes and his path to opportunity is shorter.

the WRs in my 3rd tier are pretty chalky to draft cap, in SF roughly 1.11-2.2 I have it Mingo Reed Rice Mims

Tillman is in my tier 4 WRs, where I have Downs Tillman Hyatt roughly 2.7-2.9

Mingo
Reed
Tillman

lic217 wrote: ↑Tue May 02, 2023 3:28 am Mingo my third rated wr in draft. Tillman fourth. Reed around 10th. I think Tillman and Mingo severely underrated.

And a 3rd rating might be too low.

Mingo has WR1 upside on his team quickly and should be a steady Fantasy starter for years.

mild wrote: ↑Tue May 02, 2023 4:11 am

lic217 wrote: ↑Tue May 02, 2023 3:28 am Mingo my third rated wr in draft. Tillman fourth. Reed around 10th. I think Tillman and Mingo severely underrated.

Can we see your 2023 Top 10 WR rankings out of interest?

I am somewhat doing this off the top my head, so I might be slightly off, but it’s something like this:
Tier 1
Jsn
Tier 2
Addison
Mingo
Tillman
Tier 3
QJ
Tier 4
Flowers
Tier 5
Hyatt
Downs
Mims
Tier 6
Rice
Reed
Some other guys

Keep in mind, I base my rankings Mostly on what I see in watching a little tape on each guy. I might’ve adhust tiny bit for combine results, but usually not much and then I adjust a little bit based on the draft. So, for example, if Mingo didn’t get drafting until the seventh round, I would’ve moved him down in my rankings, but just because he got picked in the second round I’m not moving the first round wide receivers ahead of him because they got picked in the first round.

Miller and spears are my third and fourth rated rbs by the war.

https://www44.myfantasyleague.com/2023/ ... 34243&O=17

This is a link to the draft I just did. I am the sewer squirrels. So you know I’m not just bullshitting I put my money where my mouth was.

lic217 wrote: ↑Tue May 02, 2023 8:07 am https://www44.myfantasyleague.com/2023/ ... 34243&O=17

This is a link to the draft I just did. I am the sewer squirrels. So you know I’m not just bullshitting I put my money where my mouth was.

Well done.

My final pre-draft rankings had the WR's as such.

T1: JSN - T2: Flowers, Addison - T3: Tillman, Johnston, Mingo T4: Reed, Mims, Hyatt, Boute - T5: Downs, Wilson & Dell.

This was after watching a lot of tape and adjusting based off that, reading scouting break downs of their games and incorporating combine numbers. Since the draft I've adjusted my board to look something like.

T1: NA - T2: JSN, Flowers, Addison - T3: Johnston,
Reed, Mingo - T4: Tillman, Mims T5: Hyatt, Downs, Wilson - T6: Boute & Dell.

Is Tillman really being selected in the same range as these guys?

It's been Mingo/Rice/Reed in all of the drafts I've been in and that grouping makes a lot more sense.