Etienne Trade (team moving towards a contender)

[Nflnz]

Team 3 in Sig:

I feel this team is starting to move into contender territory & have the 1.01 so can grab Bijan.

Would you do this trade:
Give: Etienne
Get: Aiyuk & Waller

It would give me the following line-up
QB: TLAW
RB: Bijan
RB: Ken Walker
WR: London
WR: DJ Moore
WR: Higgins
TE: Waller
FLEX: Aiyuk
FLEX: Pollard
QB: Kyler (Jimmy G, untill Kyler comes back)

Key bench pieces
RB: Pollard, Mattison, Gibson, Gainwell
WR: Cooks, Hodgins, Landry,
TE: McBride, Okonkwo

[Yarnith]

Team 3 in Sig:

I feel this team is starting to move into contender territory & have the 1.01 so can grab Bijan.

Would you do this trade:
Give: Etienne
Get: Aiyuk & Waller

It would give me the following line-up
QB: TLAW
RB: Bijan
RB: Ken Walker
WR: London
WR: DJ Moore
WR: Higgins
TE: Waller
FLEX: Aiyuk
FLEX: Pollard
QB: Kyler (Jimmy G, untill Kyler comes back)

Key bench pieces
RB: Pollard, Mattison, Gibson, Gainwell
WR: Cooks, Hodgins, Landry,
TE: McBride, Okonkwo

I would rather try to get a better TE outright or a cheaper upside TE like J Johnson or Woods with a better WR than Waller sight unseen on the NYG's.

[Gator Sens]

I would hold. Etienne has the most value to gain in the dael and is in a good spot to produce. RBs are tough to come by and I don't think this is a great deal for you.

[GridironGuerilla]

Yeah this feels like two shiny $.50 pieces for $1. Coming to the end of a rebuild with 3 solid young upside RB's is right where you want to be. I am not super high on Aiyuk as a top tier fantasy asset, he's more of a WR2/3 depth piece for me and Waller, while he may get peppered in that offense and have nice production, is certainly a declining asset. I think you would be better served keeping Etienne and retooling using other assets to upgrade at TE.

[LMS123]

No I’d take Etienne easily here, I think one of McBride or Chiggy will take a nice jump

[Nflnz]

Thanks everyone for the advice. What about Pollard for Aiyuk straight up?

[Anteaters]

I'm definitely holding Etienne in the first deal.

For the second, I am definitely on board with trading Pollard for a T20WR. I would not trade Pollard for Aiyuk. I wouldn't mind having a few shares of Aiyuk, but Pollard is too high a price ... unless you are super high on Aiyuk and you think he'll be a T20fantasy WR this season with a little upside. I'm personally not ready to go so high on Aiyuk until I see a little more from him, but it's understandable if anyone else is. If Aiyuk is THAT GUY for you, go make the deal.

[BigBawseRoss]

hell no. keep etn keep pollard or pick a different wr to target

[Paul717]

No I’d take Etienne easily here, I think one of McBride or Chiggy will take a nice jump

x2, I like both of those TEs. Also wouldn't be in a hurry to trade Pollard. I think that OP's team has enough WR weapons.