Herbert vs Lawrence

[newenglander09]

Who do we like long term?

[Gator Sens]

I don't think there is a wrong answer here and this likely comes down to preference. I am a Lawrence guy but they are pretty neck and neck in dynasty. Lawrence made a nice jump while Herbert regressed a bit thos year.

[frerichs5]

This is still Herbert for me. I’m not ready to flip based on one year. I like Lawrence as well though.

[Joshuarobbins875]

The answer is yes. Yes, to both. I know that is the cheap way out, but both are young franchise QBs that will be around the league for a very long time. If I had to pick though I would lean towards Lawrence. The tie breaker for me is the youth of the supporting cast in JAX. JAX has some young receivers and Etienne in the backfield. The skill positions are getting a little long in the tooth in LAC. Both great players and great assets to build a superflex dynasty team around.

[Anteaters]

I'm a Lawrence guy, through and through. I wouldn't argue against Herbert, but I'd choose Lawrence every time.

[Dynasty DeLorean]

I discussed this already here viewtopic.php?p=2146163#p2146163

I get it but also don’t get how anyone could take Lawrence over Herbert.

[Jigga94]

This is still Herbert for me. I’m not ready to flip based on one year. I like Lawrence as well though.

x2 here. Both should be very good for a long time

[Mjvb5]

This has been Herbert's worst of 3 years and finished with 10 more passing tds and 600 more passing yards than tlaw. Worse on the ground than Trevor but still I can't get taking Trevor over him