Would you trade Claypool for Elijah Moore?

[PBFalcon]

10 teamer. Non ppr. Team in sig.

Pretty simple question and I know that the trade calculators and trade charts say it's a no brainer but is it really a no brainer for the people on this forum?

Would you do this trade...
I give Claypool
I get Elijah Moore

I am a Claypool fan. I actually paid two late 2nd round picks for him last year. He was severely hampered by a dead armed Big Ben last year but still got 800yds. He got 800yds and 10tds the year before and looked totally like a stud. He is dealing with Diontae and Pickens this year but then is a FA I think. He has some uninspiring options at QB if he stays in Pit.

Moore looked amazing in a short spurt last year. He has continued his hype this year but now has Garrett Wilson to eat at his target share and is Zach Wilson just horrible??

Both of these negative situations could be just short term. So who is more talented? Who has a higher ceiling? Would you rather have Claypool or Moore non ppr?
Thanks.

[Gazzerk]

I would do that in a heartbeat. Not a big Claypool believer so take it as you will. I actually think Pickens starts eating away at his target share sooner than later as well.

[Gator Sens]

I think Moore is the better prospect and has shown more than Claypool already outside of the game that Claypool exploded. I don't see Claypool ever panning out and I would take the better asset overall straight up here.

[Finfansteve]

Definitely make that happen asap

[murphysxm]

yeah, the other owner is going to say no. Moore is a better value

[dblj1199]

Claypool had 2 games in his rookie season where he went nuts and scored 7 of 11 tds on the season I believe. Other than that he has been ok. I'd take Moore here pretty easily. Both have question marks at qb moving forward and both have other wr's to compete for targets with. But Moore is still the wr1 in NY where Claypool is wr 2 and could end up wr 3 with Pickens by seasons end. Take Moore.

[Disaman74]

If this is being proposed to you it’s a smash accept.
If you are proposing it, be prepared for a counter where you need to add more to claypool side

[BigBawseRoss]

id take eli. i think if the jets stink terribly they have potential to be like the cards and just take another top qb and say oops we missed last time sorry

[FiremanEd]

Elijah Moore is a much better player. I’d smash this (and get Moore) without a second hesitation.

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

If you're offered this take Moore ASAP.
If you're thinking of offering this for Moore, I would not bother.