I think you need to break this list down into 2 separate groups. The bolded QBs are off of their rookie deal while the others are either on their rookie deal or 5th year option from being a first rounder.Phaded wrote: ↑Wed May 22, 2019 3:28 pm For those that are saying to just simply draft a quarterback in the first, here is something for you to consider..
First round quarterbacks since 2008 are (brackets are exact pick): Flacco (18), Ryan (3), Freeman (17), Sanchez (5), Stafford (1), Tebow (25), Bradford (1), Ponder (12), Gabbert (10), Locker (8), Cam (1), Weeden (22), Tannehill (8), Griffin (2), Luck (1), Manuel (16), Bridgewater (32), Manziel (22), Bortles (3), Mariota (2), Winston (1), Lynch (26), Wentz (2), Goff (1), Watson (12), Mahomes (10), Trubisky (2), LJax (32), Rosen (10), Allen (7), Darnold (3), Mayfield (1), Haskins (15), Jones (6), Murray (1)
Aside from some guys drafted at the very top of the class (and even some of those are ugly), it is a very ugly list with the rare exception thrown in.
There are 19 QBs in group 1 (bold) and 16 in group 2. 3 of those 16 are this year's rookies and have yet to take a professional snap but I'll keep them in anyway.
Group 1 has 5 QBs that I would call successful: Flacco, Ryan, Stafford, Cam, and Luck. Flacco is the only one to win a SB and he did it on his rookie deal. Cam and Matt Ryan made the SB, but their teams have largely been above average over their careers. Stafford has been in no man's land his entire career. Luck is the best of this group by far, but has yet to make a SB.
Group 2 currently has 4 QBs that I would call successful right now: Wentz, Goff, Watson, Mahomes. Wentz probably would have bee MVP 2 seasons ago if he didn't get injured. Mahomes was MVP as a rookie. Goff has been to a SB and Watson has been very good when healthy.
If you are good with those numbers, then would have a 26% hit rate in that first group and a 25% hit rate in group 2. However, if you remove the 3 rookies that puts the hit rate at just under 31%. If Baker has another good year he goes on this list. You would probably have to do the same for Trubisky if he succeeds next year as well. If 2 more QBs make the jump that would put your hit rate at 37.5% for that group. That is a very large jump from group 1. Teams would have to ask themselves if this is just a good crop of QBs or was the previous group bad. Or have teams started to do things the last 5 years to help their QBs transition better? Or maybe with all the new rules to help out the passing game it has made it easier for young QBs to be successful? Lots of variables and factors here, but if you have another jump like that over the next 5 years, it will be easier to just treat the QB like other positions and recycle with young talent. I'm not saying the league is there yet, but I won't be shocked if some organization tries this strategy within the next 5 years or so.