Dynasty League Football Forum

What are your thoughts on this offer?

Im not a Cook believer and am higher than Sutton than most. I think its pretty even and come down to personal opinion but Id take the Howard side.

fair deal i would prob take the howard side. cook played well in his 4 games but i cant imagine hes that much better than howard and i like sutton a lot

I don't think there's a large gap between Cook and Howard, but Sutton is meh. If you can get a late 1st instead, I'd do that.

Fair offer. Cook>Howard but Sutton makes it pretty even. Personal preference to me. Mine is still Cook but really an even offer.

Wow....This isn't even close to me, I have cook as a top 8 potentially top 7 RB in my opinion, Howard is probably around 15. a rookie WR that is stuck behind 2 solid vets for at least a year potentially 2 with a mediocre QB doesn't come close to closing the gap. I would strongly advise was away from the ledge on this one.

Cook was a STUD in the 4 games he played in, is one a high flying offense that won't be able to stack the box against him and has one of the best defenses in the NFL, how many positive game scripts do you think he'll have? Tons. McKinnon also just vacated 53 receptions and Murray certainly isn't taking those...

id rather have howard than cook right now so gimme howard side rather easily

Fair deal.

This is some crazy advice people are giving.....

as of July ADP is as follows:

Dalvin Cook: 14
Howard: 41


Would any of you seriously trade pick 2.2 in a startup for pick 4.5 and a late 1st?

Titans95 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 7:56 am This is some crazy advice people are giving.....

as of July ADP is as follows:

Dalvin Cook: 14
Howard: 41


Would any of you seriously trade pick 2.2 in a startup for pick 4.5 and a late 1st?

cook is massively overpriced doesnt change my mind set id rather have howard

knotts4372 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 8:05 am

Titans95 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 7:56 am This is some crazy advice people are giving.....

as of July ADP is as follows:

Dalvin Cook: 14
Howard: 41


Would any of you seriously trade pick 2.2 in a startup for pick 4.5 and a late 1st?

cook is massively overpriced doesnt change my mind set id rather have howard

So you'll be drafting Howard over Cook is redraft leagues? Howard is a 2 down thumper on a mediocre offense, Cook is a 3 down work horse on an elite offense and elite defense

Titans95 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 7:56 am This is some crazy advice people are giving.....

as of July ADP is as follows:

Dalvin Cook: 14
Howard: 41


Would any of you seriously trade pick 2.2 in a startup for pick 4.5 and a late 1st?

I'm very high on Cook, but I think his ADP of 14 is a bit generous and overhyped. And the opposite goes for Howard where he's pretty underrated by a lot of the fantasy community. I think the deal is fair, but can see Cook owners not wanting to do this.

Titans95 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 8:17 am

knotts4372 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 8:05 am

Titans95 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 7:56 am This is some crazy advice people are giving.....

as of July ADP is as follows:

Dalvin Cook: 14
Howard: 41


Would any of you seriously trade pick 2.2 in a startup for pick 4.5 and a late 1st?

cook is massively overpriced doesnt change my mind set id rather have howard

So you'll be drafting Howard over Cook is redraft leagues? Howard is a 2 down thumper on a mediocre offense, Cook is a 3 down work horse on an elite offense and elite defense

yes i indeed would take howard over cook in redraft.

Goddard wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 8:39 am

Titans95 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 7:56 am This is some crazy advice people are giving.....

as of July ADP is as follows:

Dalvin Cook: 14
Howard: 41


Would any of you seriously trade pick 2.2 in a startup for pick 4.5 and a late 1st?

I'm very high on Cook, but I think his ADP of 14 is a bit generous and overhyped. And the opposite goes for Howard where he's pretty underrated by a lot of the fantasy community. I think the deal is fair, but can see Cook owners not wanting to do this.

i can understand if you want to say Cook is overvalued and Howard is undervalued but I just cannot get behind a late 1st/early 2nd is the gap between the too. Cook has just as safe of a floor as howard with a much much higher ceiling...Sutton is going to stay behind Sanders and DT for at least 1 maybe 2 years before starting and has a mediocre Qb throwing to him. I also definitely can't get behind Howard>=cook in anyway, especially redraft, I could join 50 leagues and wouldn't see howard go before cook in any of them

Titans95 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 9:03 am

Goddard wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 8:39 am

Titans95 wrote: ↑Tue Jul 24, 2018 7:56 am This is some crazy advice people are giving.....

as of July ADP is as follows:

Dalvin Cook: 14
Howard: 41


Would any of you seriously trade pick 2.2 in a startup for pick 4.5 and a late 1st?

I'm very high on Cook, but I think his ADP of 14 is a bit generous and overhyped. And the opposite goes for Howard where he's pretty underrated by a lot of the fantasy community. I think the deal is fair, but can see Cook owners not wanting to do this.

i can understand if you want to say Cook is overvalued and Howard is undervalued but I just cannot get behind a late 1st/early 2nd is the gap between the too. Cook has just as safe of a floor as howard with a much much higher ceiling...Sutton is going to stay behind Sanders and DT for at least 1 maybe 2 years before starting and has a mediocre Qb throwing to him. I also definitely can't get behind Howard>=cook in anyway, especially redraft, I could join 50 leagues and wouldn't see howard go before cook in any of them

so lets get this straight. you think cook has a safe floor when he has injury and off field concerns, and really only 1 REAL good game under his belt? come on now, don't play yourself