https://forum.dynastyleaguefootball.com/
https://forum.dynastyleaguefootball.com/viewtopic.php?t=164063
I appreciate you and youre time you put into this response!moishetreats wrote: ↑Mon Jun 25, 2018 8:01 am As of 5 votes, I am the only one to vote for the Rodgers side.
Here's why. You only start 9 players, so studs are key. As your team was, you're set at 7 or 8 positions, depending on you view CMC and Hill. And you have plenty of options to rotate your 9th player week-to-week.
Yes, depth is an issue. But, this trade barely helps. It improves your final starter to Allen, no doubt, but doesn't do much for depth. And the cost at QB is MASSIVE.
IMO, Dak is the second-best QB in this trade. But, let's presume that Dak is worst for a moment. He's still pretty close to the lesser of Cousins or Stafford. But, the difference between the stronger of those two and Rodgers is massive. Given the elite names being traded, the 2019 1st to 2nd is a loss but not a deal-breaker. I would MUCH rather have the combo of Rodgers and Dak than Cousins and Stafford, and it is nowhere near close for me. The upgrade from Doctson and Allison and from a 2nd to a 1st isn't nearly enough, IMO, to close the gap.
You're welcome!playa_hata wrote: ↑Mon Jun 25, 2018 11:22 amI appreciate you and youre time you put into this response!moishetreats wrote: ↑Mon Jun 25, 2018 8:01 am As of 5 votes, I am the only one to vote for the Rodgers side.
Here's why. You only start 9 players, so studs are key. As your team was, you're set at 7 or 8 positions, depending on you view CMC and Hill. And you have plenty of options to rotate your 9th player week-to-week.
Yes, depth is an issue. But, this trade barely helps. It improves your final starter to Allen, no doubt, but doesn't do much for depth. And the cost at QB is MASSIVE.
IMO, Dak is the second-best QB in this trade. But, let's presume that Dak is worst for a moment. He's still pretty close to the lesser of Cousins or Stafford. But, the difference between the stronger of those two and Rodgers is massive. Given the elite names being traded, the 2019 1st to 2nd is a loss but not a deal-breaker. I would MUCH rather have the combo of Rodgers and Dak than Cousins and Stafford, and it is nowhere near close for me. The upgrade from Doctson and Allison and from a 2nd to a 1st isn't nearly enough, IMO, to close the gap.
also i value tyreek as a wr1 and top dynasty asset but i dont value cmc much at all i could probably get keenan for cmc but would really deplete my little depth at rb