Dynasty League Football Forum

I received this offer, after some back and forth. He was interested in Josh Gordon, so I made a trade offer. Now he has asked for Melvin as well. Melvin is the best player in the trade. He really has no other good player on his roster, or one that I'd want.

His 2018 picks are #3 and #15. I have #2, 11, and 18. My plan was to move mid players and upgrade and make room to draft rookies. By moving Melvin, I'd have to draft 2 RBs at #2-3

My original offer was:
Josh Gordon, Derrick Henry, Chris Hogan, my 2018 #1 (11 overall), a 2018 2nd round (18th), and my 2019 3rd round pick
For his 2018 #1 pick (#3) and Alshon Jeffery.

Thoughts, suggestions? Say no and walk away?

Thanks in advance

It comes down to your interest/evaluation of Josh Gordon. If you think he can be a players and be clean, keep the Gordons. Otherwise, it's more than a fair price for them.

Alshon Jeffery = Josh Gordon + 2.03
Melvin Gordon > 1.03
I'd counter by asking him to add his 2019 2nd to the existing offer.