Dynasty League Football Forum

i feel like this is a good debate wondering who u see as more valuable as a fantasy asset and why ?

Wrong forum, should go in Player Debates section. However, I will say that I just finished a dynasty startup and Mahomes was picked before Carr. I picked Mahomes in rookie drafts before Trubisky and Watson last year as it seemed like he had the most upside, strongest arm and went to the best situation (under Andy Reid and not having to start in year 1). As for Carr, it seemed like he took a giant step back last year...was it because his offensive line didn't block as well, or that Cooper and Crabtree both were disappointing and dropped a lot of passes or other factors? A lot of people seem to think that hiring Gruden will really help Carr get back on track.

Not a Mahomes fan so it's pretty easily Carr for me. I think Reid made a mistake moving Alex Smith this soon and the Chiefs will be taking steps backward before moving forward again.

I like Mahomes a lot, but it has to be Carr. He's proven, and my hope with Mahomes is that he can be what Carr has been. I like Andy Reid better for Mahomes than Gruden for Carr, but I'd want added cap to Mahomes to reach Carr value. Going forward I'd have to aim for the proven gunslinger before the projected gunslinger.

Carr

Mahomes

Carr...all day...Mahomes has potential, Carr is proven and has solid WRs

Carr. He's shown he can be a good QB. While Mahomes is intriguing, I still don't know what to expect from him.

Carr. For the same reasons. Proven vs hopefully good.

I would pick Carr but I do like Mahomes potential