Dynasty League Football Forum

POLL

Which back do you like more?
Which back would you consider sending in a deal for 1.01 Pick?

Dynasty Browns Sig

I have both.. I still don't know who I value more. Dead even imo. Lol

Gotta say this is weird. CMac and Mixon are neck and neck all offseason in ADP after the draft, then McCaffery outscores Mixon by 80+points, and now Mixon has a huge lead here. Not even sure it’s wrong, just seems weird.

I own both as well and wanted to ship C Mac in a package for the 1.1, owner won't even consider C Mac and stated the deal must involve Mixon

Maximus891 wrote: ↑Tue Feb 13, 2018 6:35 am I own both as well and wanted to ship C Mac in a package for the 1.1, owner won't even consider C Mac and stated the deal must involve Mixon

Right? This feels nuts.

Maximus891 wrote: ↑Tue Feb 13, 2018 6:35 am I own both as well and wanted to ship C Mac in a package for the 1.1, owner won't even consider C Mac and stated the deal must involve Mixon

I agree it seems a bit phenomenal, but it may have something to do with the fact that we actually watched what the 2 RBs played like on film? Mixon looked like a future all-pro. CMC looked like Theo Riddick.

lukkynumber13 wrote: ↑Wed Feb 14, 2018 2:39 am

Maximus891 wrote: ↑Tue Feb 13, 2018 6:35 am I own both as well and wanted to ship C Mac in a package for the 1.1, owner won't even consider C Mac and stated the deal must involve Mixon

I agree it seems a bit phenomenal, but it may have something to do with the fact that we actually watched what the 2 RBs played like on film? Mixon looked like a future all-pro. CMC looked like Theo Riddick.

This for me to. Cmc just didn't look like a good runner at all.

lukkynumber13 wrote: ↑Wed Feb 14, 2018 2:39 am

Maximus891 wrote: ↑Tue Feb 13, 2018 6:35 am I own both as well and wanted to ship C Mac in a package for the 1.1, owner won't even consider C Mac and stated the deal must involve Mixon

I agree it seems a bit phenomenal, but it may have something to do with the fact that we actually watched what the 2 RBs played like on film? Mixon looked like a future all-pro. CMC looked like Theo Riddick.

X2
When watching the tape Mixon looks night and day better..
I’d have Mixon as the clear cut #2 if he was in this class not sure where I’d rank Caff but doubtful I’d move the #6 that I’m not even high on for Caff.

I think CMC's season was pretty close to what his ceiling is going to be...which isn't a bad thing. As for Mixon, most didn't expect him to come out and dominate year one. There have been several barriers that have been discussed way too much already for me to repeat. Most people still believe that Mixon will continue to get better and be in the elite category of RBs with guys like Bell.

Mixon>Mac

Guessing it would take both for Barkely hype 1.1 2018 ?

Barkely > Mixon, Mac

Agree with most others, I prefer Mixon and would trade cmac++ for Barkley. In 2 years I don't think Mixon and Barkley will be too far apart in value and you'll regret trading him