Dynasty League Football Forum

Which one rest of THIS year?

I voted Carson, but I think it's close between him and Cohen. I'm going with the guy I think offers more ceiling

I think Carson ascends and Cohen gets broken... poor lil feller.

I voted Carson. It may in fact be Cohen for the next 2-3 weeks- but after that I believe it will be all Carson.

In ppr, I'll take White for THIS year. He's going to be the only RB on that team with a clear role and be used extensively in the passing game.

Carson.

Goddard wrote: ↑Mon Sep 18, 2017 3:18 pm In ppr, I'll take White for THIS year. He's going to be the only RB on that team with a clear role and be used extensively in the passing game.

Gillislee 15 carries per game along with a TD per game is not a clear role?

Carson has the highest ceiling, but clearly the lowest floor.
If we are relying on PPR scoring, I'd rather have Cohen, then James White. The bears have to have Cohen involved, there is no one else on that team.

remedy29 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 19, 2017 8:22 pm

Goddard wrote: ↑Mon Sep 18, 2017 3:18 pm In ppr, I'll take White for THIS year. He's going to be the only RB on that team with a clear role and be used extensively in the passing game.

Gillislee 15 carries per game along with a TD per game is not a clear role?

Carson has the highest ceiling, but clearly the lowest floor.
If we are relying on PPR scoring, I'd rather have Cohen, then James White. The bears have to have Cohen involved, there is no one else on that team.

Agree with Goddard. I think it's more likely Gillislee's role fluctuates this season (depending on the matchup) than White. White has a clearly defined role in that offense and Brady absolutely loves and trusts him. We know what White is, low ceiling/high floor, and we know he can handle the rigors of the NFL within that role.

Cohen on the other hand seems like a bigger part of the Bears offense, but will he be able to stay healthy? Will he be able to keep up his production as teams prep for him? It's possible, but if we're just talking about this season, I vote White.

Carson is tempting, but I don't think Rawls is out of the picture yet.

Where would you put Perine in this group? (things in the league have changed since I posted this)

VinniVidiVici wrote: ↑Fri Sep 22, 2017 9:17 am Where would you put Perine in this group? (things in the league have changed since I posted this)

How far down the list can we put Perine?

Cohen is extremely impressive. I dismissed him due to his size, but but he is clearly the top option of these three.