Zeke owner just sent me an offer

[chadtriumph]

12 team ppr
My roster:
Luck
Mccaffery, Hyde, Mixon, Abdullah, T. Coleman, Hunt, J. Charles, Dixon, T. West, J. Conner
M. Thomas, Arob, Keenan, D. Adams, D. Parker, C. Davis, Maclin, Jmatt and White
Gronk, Hooper and Fleener
Solid IDP depth

So, the Zeke owner (he doesn't have the strongest starting lineup or depth) offered me:
Zeke and Mariota
For
Luck, Mixon, Mccaffery, C. Davis and Calais Campbell

At first look I felt that I was giving up too much value, but I have the depth to overpay for him. Any thought?

[Shoreline Steamers]

Call me risk-averse, a rookie hype buyer, too attached to "my guys" or whatever. But man, he sure is asking for a lot. More than I'd be willing to pay. I can't speak to the IDP component, But it's certainly 4 high-first rounders and an IDP for 2 1st's.

And I think it would pretty much eliminate your chances at competing this year unless Hyde, Abdullah, and West start out hot and stay healthy.

[ADrunkenCaveman]

I think I would be fine moving 2 of Mixon/CMC/Davis + Luck + Campbell FOR Mariota + Zeke
I think thats already a slight overpay, but I would want to keep 1 of Mixon or CMC (Mixon preferably) because you have a bunch of depth at rb even without Mixon or CMC, but no true rb2 besides Hyde who I am very low on.

[cptjonesb]

That is a tough offer to digest. I see the Luck / Mariota part being pretty equal so no issue there. So that leaves
Mixon, CMC, Davis, Campbell for Zeke

That seems like a little bit of an overpay but your WR depth is fine without Davis and you say you have good IDP depth so the question is can you give up the RB depth to get Zeke. My gut on this one says yes you can as I like Coleman, Hyde and the BAL RBs

[RB6]

Pass. Too much for my liking.

[chadtriumph]

Yeah, it is a hard offer to swallow. If I could keep one of the Mixon or CMC, I'd feel more comfortable with making the deal. I do appreciate all the feedback, fellas.

[Eight7Seven]

That's a decline and counter for me. I would give up every player in that package in a deal for Zeke, but I'd want more with him to give up them all. I'd probably drop both QB's (I'm lower on Mariota then the consensus) and add in his first round pick next year and hit send.

[SteveMaddensShoes]

Giant pass.

Atleast one rookie too many. Zeke has a better chance of getting banned than they do of all busting.

[IR1]

Too rich for me

[Spongehack]

Luck > Mariota, Mixon, CMC, Davis, Calais > Zeke

Don't do it.

[Fantasy>>>Reality]

Too much, I'd pass

[rubber_duck]

Zeke has a better chance of getting banned than they do of all busting.

And that is where I'm at as well.

[EAGLES]

Giving up way too much for Zeke in this offer. Pass

[saw061600]

This is the exact opposite of the offer I expected to see when I clicked on the post. Zeke out 6 weeks, NFL acting towards Zeke like Jules to that poor dumb Kid in Pulp Fiction (Do something stupid again MFr!!!), and guy asks for the max possible value? Crazy.

[lukkynumber13]

That's a decline and counter for me. I would give up every player in that package in a deal for Zeke, but I'd want more with him to give up them all. I'd probably drop both QB's (I'm lower on Mariota then the consensus) and add in his first round pick next year and hit send.

X2