Dynasty League Football Forum

So assuming Darnold is the #1 QB for 2018 because he has the most hype, which of the next 2 do you prefer? Josh Rosen or Josh Allen?

I think its neck an neck personally an this year will be huge for both players, in a one rd 16 team devy draft of draft eligible players i did two weeks ago allen went like 1.8 darnold 1.11 an rosen 1.16 if that helps......

Haven't spent much effort looking into Allen. Rosen, however, is starting to show signs of being a bust. His head doesn't appear to be on quite straight. He has been publicly called out by the coach. There are rumblings that he is not well liked in the locker room. The famous hot tub photo (by itself means little/nothing) just adds to the pile.

I will stay far away from QB prospects that don't appear to be rock solid in the head department. The position is difficult enough to succeed in without having to overcome those types of issues.

Just completed a college 2-QB auction draft ($1,000 budget). For what ever it's worth, Rosen went for $136 and Allen went for $140. Further comparison, Darnold went for $193.

I prefer Josh Allen and can't wait to see the season he has.

Haven't watched much of rosen but allen for all his apparent physical skills reminds me of jake locker or jay cutler type . Inaccurate and reckless with the football.

clarion contrarion wrote: ↑Sat Jul 22, 2017 3:08 am Haven't watched much of rosen but allen for all his apparent physical skills reminds me of jake locker or jay cutler type . Inaccurate and reckless with the football.

Agree. While Allen has a great arm, no weapons to speak of, I have been underwhelmed watching his games.

Rosen, despite the head case debate, makes all the throws, has zero run game and defense to speak of. Playing against better competition, Rosen has looked far superior to Allen. Darnold with all hype will have to be reeled back by an NFL QB coach.

This QB class actually looks terrible

Cherokee wrote: ↑Tue Nov 07, 2017 12:34 am This QB class actually looks terrible

Maybe as a whole, but there's at least 1 QB I like better than anyone coming out last year.

I think this entire rookie class in all offensive positions is going to be very top heavy. Last year's had a ton of depth and not very top heavy.

Dynasty DeLorean wrote: ↑Thu Nov 09, 2017 3:17 pm

Cherokee wrote: ↑Tue Nov 07, 2017 12:34 am This QB class actually looks terrible

Maybe as a whole, but there's at least 1 QB I like better than anyone coming out last year.

I think this entire rookie class in all offensive positions is going to be very top heavy. Last year's had a ton of depth and not very top heavy.

This year, seems really hard to tell for Qbs and WRs. There is no consensus about who will be the first QB and who will be the first WR.

So far i only looked at walterfootball and cbs sports for prospects rankings and both are so different.

I will have to look at some videos and make my own ideas.