Dynasty League Football Forum

Taylor landing in Tennessee and Godwin to Tampa are both intriguing spots...

I think Godwin is the more talented player.

Yeah I agree that Godwin is the more talented player but Taylor landed in the better situation, in my opinion. Godwin has more guys to beat out.

Long term I think Godwin but Taylor should be able to push for more time this year.

Godwin i think in the short term and long...

i think one of the biggest losers coming out of this offseason is Mike Evans...not that he isnt absolultely special and an amazing talent but jameis is a damn good QB who will spread it around and now has 2 legit seam options in brate/howard and a nice physical receir to pair with evans and a great streaker in DJax.

ManhattanProject wrote: ↑Sat Apr 29, 2017 5:54 am Long term I think Godwin but Taylor should be able to push for more time this year.

Agree with that. Once DeSean Jackson retires in a couple years Godwin will be a stud.

benpickering44 wrote: ↑Sat Apr 29, 2017 2:50 pm

ManhattanProject wrote: ↑Sat Apr 29, 2017 5:54 am Long term I think Godwin but Taylor should be able to push for more time this year.

Agree with that. Once DeSean Jackson retires in a couple years Godwin will be a stud.

They're going to have a lot of mouths to feed. Evans will remain the #1 no matter what. He's proven that much. Howard will command his fair share of targets. I think his ceiling will be capped due to all the mouths to feed, but I could easily see a great WR2 for years to come if he pans out.

I like both of these landing spots. I think Godwin is more talented, and Taylor has a shallower depth chart. I've been having a similar argument all weekend with Godwin. I'm not concerned with DeSean, Evans, Howard or McNichols. I'm not concerned with depth or mouths to feed. When Godwin gets his opportunity he will be in an offense that throws the ball 4,000 yards a season.

They both are going to fight to be their team's 4th target.

Godwin will fight to get right behind Evans, DJax, & Howard. Maybe the white boy too, at least in year 1.

Taylor will fight to get right behind Davis, Walker, & Matthews.

Taylor has an insignificant edge in pedigree (12 spots in the 3rd round)

End result? Godwin wins for me, for 2 reasons:
1. He was the much more touted prospect pre draft (late first, early 2nd), as opposed to Taylor who was usually seen as a late 2nd or early 3rd guy in rookie drafts.
2. While both offenses are seeking to dominate via the ground & pound game, I'll bet on Winston long term to be able to support 2-3 fantasy weapons.

To me Taylor is the more dynamic talent and really my only worry is whether his transition to the NFL will be smooth based off Harmon's analysis of alignment for collegiate WRs. I think Godwin has been massively overhyped by the dynasty community and Taywan, to me, can be an elite slot receiver in the NFL. Don't let him slip ladies and gentlemen

Taylor is an under the radar stud. Did y'all see what he did to Alabama in '16?

Godwin is a bit overhyped, not much, just a bit. He went to a big name program and did well so his name has floated around a lot more than Taylor.

I don't see how Taylor would be fighting for targets against Matthews... he doesn't really have much hinderance with Kendall Wright gone. Give me Taylor and that situation slightly over Godwin. I think their talent is more even than people think.

I do see Taylor as the one with better chance to produce in 2017 but like Godwin long - term as I think just a bit more talented and give me Winston over Mariota long term as well. See him as solid WR 2 for dynasty. Neither in redraft this year.

CK_ wrote: ↑Wed May 03, 2017 3:20 am Taylor is an under the radar stud. Did y'all see what he did to Alabama in '16?

Godwin is a bit overhyped, not much, just a bit. He went to a big name program and did well so his name has floated around a lot more than Taylor.

If Godwin went to Alabama he would be the consensus #1 rookie receiver. He is still underhyped. Ross, Smith-Schuster and Jones will all have worse careers.

Situation v talent....I am hoping I snag both in my draft.

Like the idea of going for them both. I got Godwin at the 3.03 and Taylor still not off the board going into the 4th. If he's there at 4.11 for I'm jumping on that train.