Ha! what a great thread and fun read (some great pissing contests in here). I think I got called out for not referencing Nuks 2014 season, so here's my thoughts on that.
I project nuks future outlook to be much like his 2014 season. I believe I stated that he's still a good WR and should be somewhere in the WR8-WR16 range. Well looking back, in 2014 Nuk was the WR14 in total pts, WR21 in targets, and WR18 in points per game.
http://www.fftoday.com/stats/playerstat ... order=DESC
That's about what I see for him moving fwd based on all the previous arguments made here (market share, targets, internal competition, poor qb play). Don't take it personally and get venomous in an attempt to prove he should be a elite top 5 WR. He simply isn't, he's good but not elite, and his 2015 production was a huge outlier propped up by target volume.
In the past 25 years only 10 players have received more targets then him in a single season (re: Nuks 2015 target totals). That kind of volume just doesn't happen, it was a perfect storm. So don't hitch your wagon to 2015 because it likely won't happen again. Lucky for you Dhop owners that repeats of 2014 could, and prob will happen...eventually. Just be happy that you'll still likely have a great WR8-WR16 level guy.
Also, the entire "he could leave in FA" argument wouldn't be the hill I die on. Routinely offensive players that change teams in FA are often not the bill of goods that they are made out to be. It's usually almost always due to a ton of puff pieces that get everyone all riled up in the offseason when we are starved for football and anything will satisfy our hunger for the game. We think they'll be great, and that "this will be the year, now that they have an opportunity on team x" blah blah blah. Almost never pans out, although there's an exception to every rule so I guess I should say 3/4 never work out the way we anticipate them to. If you wanna believe Dhop will be the exception that's your prerogative, I'd rather play the odds myself on that one.
I personally don't wanna just sit and wait for Dhop to get in a better situation so I'd make that trade. That said, because it's quite obvious that the dynasty community still is clinging to that 2015 season, I'd ask for the 1.01++.
Even if you don't think that the 1.01 will be a better player then Dhop (I personally think they will but that doesn't matter for this argument), the 1.01 will be "worth" quite a bit more than Dhop when the draft rolls around and everyone gets infected with rookie fever.
So I say make the trade, get 1.01+, then trade the 1.01 at draft time if you don't want it for a kings ransom. I would estimate that with your tidy return on investment you could prob get Nuk back for less than you originally paid, and gain some dynasty assets for free essentially. NTM trading is fun, basically the best part of dynasty. I mean, that's why we all prob started posting on these boards in the first place right.
I take it as a good sign that most think the ppl favoring the 1.01 side are off base. It means that there's still deals to be made and value to obtain. Lots of times in my leagues, ppl will scratch their heads at my trades and call me out, only to kick themselves a few months later for not seeing what "could" be. Do they all work out, no, but most of the time we regret the risks we didn't take. I'm sure we all have a few trades, we declined at one time and regret not making now.
Take a risk and make a trade. It's not like owning Dhop is fun or helping you win, at least this way your offseason will be a blast
If you don't wanna take my word for it, here's another person that thinks the 1.01 will worth more than Nuk. Have a read.
http://rotoviz.com/2016/11/where-will-t ... vid=4lgrLV