Jeremy hill for John brown straight up?

[roofy61]

Thoughts? I'd be buying Hill

[dblj1199]

I'm not a Brown fan, I think he's to inconsistent to be a weekly play. Hill had a average year two but I think he will rebound. I'll take hill.

[Moneyball_85]

I'm not a fan of Hill. I think Brown will be consistent this season. Hill hasn't earned the trust of his coaching staff and he's had a few years to prove himself. Give Brown a shot. Larry Fitz is on borrowed time.

[Flathead]

Hill for me, you have Floyd as well so makes sense to move Brown. Hill had 12 TD's last year, on a bad day he's a low end rb2.

[EmmanuelG]

Hill for me too. I like brown but I think hill will bounce back in his yardage this year.

[KMA]

Hill all day

[RB6]

Gimme Hill.

[giveahoot]

Damn - i clicked into this thread expecting to see a ton of people taking the brown side. The value is certain on John Brown. Their startup ADP (I know not perfect for analyzing trades) is a difference of 42!!!

39 - John Brown
81 - Jeremy Hill

With that in mind - if you really want hill you should be able to at least get a 2nd in that trade, maybe another lottery ticket player or a 3rd as well. or for shoot for someone a bit higher if you want to go straight up. Doug Martin, Mark Ingram, Lacy, Hyde, AP, all have later ADP's than him. Not saying owners will value them similarly in a trade but don't sell yourself short

[The Fantasy Feud]

Damn - i clicked into this thread expecting to see a ton of people taking the brown side. The value is certain on John Brown. Their startup ADP (I know not perfect for analyzing trades) is a difference of 42!!!

39 - John Brown
81 - Jeremy Hill

With that in mind - if you really want hill you should be able to at least get a 2nd in that trade, maybe another lottery ticket player or a 3rd as well. or for shoot for someone a bit higher if you want to go straight up. Doug Martin, Mark Ingram, Lacy, Hyde, AP, all have later ADP's than him. Not saying owners will value them similarly in a trade but don't sell yourself short

ADP can be skewed by people taking their favorite players for example very early changing the adp drastically.

[cane]

brown ..watching film last year hill looked terrible and benard looked like the better back in espect except short yardage..im suprised they didnt cut his workload even more

[vicferrari]

Hill. Feel like his floor is RB2 low end and Brown's ceiling is WR2

[Eight7Seven]

While I like Hill more then Brown I don't see him helping you. Your team doesn't seem possible in a sixteen team league, you'd be favored to win in a ten team league. I have Hill well behind David Johnson, Miller & Hyde. With Melvin Gordon and Matt Jones in house you don't even need Hill for bench depth.

While I don't see Brown breaking into your starting line up, he could more easily help you off the bench then Hill. I can't conceive of how this team came to be. You're loaded with some of the top tier players at every single position.

[roofy61]

Thanks for all the input. Its been a great adventure taking this team over 3 years ago. When i started i had crap and the Bengals defense and Gostowski. had the good fortune of some really good drafts. I should have kept a log. Lamar Miller, Rivers and Jordan Matthews are the only guys i traded for, rest were draft picks.

[Coogan Football]

Thanks for all the input.

Quite a few of these forum members that commented also have their own threads going, you should return the favor and help them with theirs.

[BelichekYourSelf]

John Brown very easily for me here. Give me the best WR on the Cardinals over a RB who in the worse half of a RBBC.