Dynasty League Football Forum

I'm looking to try and acquire a qb from an owner that has too many currently on his roster. I'm getting ready to move M. Ryan to climb up in draft. With that being said, what would you offer for Alex Smith or Leinert? I'm positive he will be drafting a RB at 1.2. I don't have a problem making the trade bigger than just trading for a QB.

Here is his team...

QB: McNabb, Al. Smith, Kolb, Leinert
RB: P. Thomas, LT, McFadden, Jennings, Forsett
WR: Calvin, Marshall, TO, Mossaqui, L. Murphy
TE: Celek, Carlson

Pick: 1.2, 2.2

gunslinger wrote:I'm looking to try and acquire a qb from an owner that has too many currently on his roster. I'm getting ready to move M. Ryan to climb up in draft. With that being said, what would you offer for Alex Smith or Leinert? I'm positive he will be drafting a RB at 1.2. I don't have a problem making the trade bigger than just trading for a QB.

Here is his team...

QB: McNabb, Al. Smith, Kolb, Leinert
RB: P. Thomas, LT, McFadden, Jennings, Forsett
WR: Calvin, Marshall, TO, Mossaqui, L. Murphy
TE: Celek, Carlson

Pick: 1.2, 2.2

why on earth would you want to move matty ice...

I have no issue with trading Ryan if there were a reason to do so. But your roster is solid with no real needs. I'm curious what the ultimate goal is here?

skip wrote:I have no issue with trading Ryan if there were a reason to do so. But your roster is solid with no real needs. I'm curious what the ultimate goal is here?

you already have the 1.5 and 1.9 picks....

so your looking to move ryan for alex smith and a pick? QB's have a massive bust potential and while ryan may never be peyton manning, he is no bust

I wouldn't give much more than a 2nd round pick for either Leinart or Smith. I agree with moving Ryan though since Rodgers is your franchise QB. I would look to move him in a package for an upgrade at WR.

I play M. Ryan one game a year. I'm in the process of trading (different team) M. Ryan and 1.5 for 1.3, Henne, and 2.3. This would allow me to get either Matthews, Spiller or Dez (probably Dez). When this gets completed, I will be left with A-Rod, Henne, and T. Jackson at QB. I think I could get 1 of these 2 QB's from him cheap, since he is going to have to move 1 of them. It's not a move that I have to make, just thinking I could get good value there.

gunslinger wrote:I play M. Ryan one game a year. I'm in the process of trading (different team) M. Ryan and 1.5 for 1.3, Henne, and 2.3. This would allow me to get either Matthews, Spiller or Dez (probably Dez). When this gets completed, I will be left with A-Rod, Henne, and T. Jackson at QB. I think I could get 1 of these 2 QB's from him cheap, since he is going to have to move 1 of them. It's not a move that I have to make, just thinking I could get good value there.

So you're moving Ryan to move up to 1.03 right? And you still want Smith or Leinart from a different owner. Why not just offer your Ryan/1.05 for Smith/Leinart/1.02?

The owner will not come off of the 2.

You don't need to offer anymore than the 2.3 you will acquire if you decide to move up to 1.3.

Both offers are now off the table. I am going to work on coming up with something new.