Help with my QBs

[JayT]

I'm trying to figure out what direction to head with my keepers and most specifically my QBs. We can only keep 10 position players (QB/RB/WRs) for next year.

Here are my potential keepers:
QB - McNabb, V.Young, Sanchez, Cassel
RB - Stewart, Moreno, P.Thomas, Bradshaw
WR - Jennings, Nicks, A.Bryant, Cotchery, Jacoby Jones, James Jones

My plan was to keep 3 QB, 4 RB, 3 WR.

I'm worried about McNabb's value with a potential trade away from Philly. Trying to see if we can work a deal for Kolb.

How would you value those 5 QBs (the 4 I have plus Kolb)? I have a tentative deal to trade V.Young for 2.06 (12 team league)...any thoughts on this deal?

What would you be willing to deal for Kolb? Do you think a 2nd round pick would be reasonable?

Who would you keep as the 3rd WR after Jennings and Nicks?

[skip]

QB - McNabb, V.Young, Sanchez
RB - Stewart, Moreno, P.Thomas
WR - Jennings, Nicks, A.Bryant, Cotchery


These would be my keepers. I am not big on Bradshaw, but I am sure you will get some who are. If I did opt to keep him, I would probably dump Sanchez to do it.

You have your QBs listed in the right order. Keep Young, he is worth more than the 2.6. You aren't touching Kolb with a 2nd rd pick.

[meineymoe]

I would not trade away Young for the 2.06, but if you prefer Kolb, see if you can do a three way trade where you end up with Kolb, give Young, and the 2.06 goes to the Kolb owner.

I'm up in the air on your 10th protect - I like Bradshaw and not as excited about your WR option beyond Jennings/Nicks/Bryant. Might depend on your starting requirements.............................

-oo-

[Steelersfan]

I'm trying to figure out what direction to head with my keepers and most specifically my QBs. We can only keep 10 position players (QB/RB/WRs) for next year.

Here are my potential keepers:
QB - McNabb, V.Young, Sanchez, Cassel
RB - Stewart, Moreno, P.Thomas, Bradshaw
WR - Jennings, Nicks, A.Bryant, Cotchery, Jacoby Jones, James Jones

My plan was to keep 3 QB, 4 RB, 3 WR.

I'm worried about McNabb's value with a potential trade away from Philly. Trying to see if we can work a deal for Kolb.

How would you value those 5 QBs (the 4 I have plus Kolb)? I have a tentative deal to trade V.Young for 2.06 (12 team league)...any thoughts on this deal? Keep Young

What would you be willing to deal for Kolb? Do you think a 2nd round pick would be reasonable? Yes, but good luck...

Who would you keep as the 3rd WR after Jennings and Nicks?

[JayT]

So do you think Young is more valuable than 2.06 and Cassel?

[Steelersfan]

So do you think Young is more valuable than 2.06 and Cassel?

Yes.

[JayT]

If we can swing a deal for Kolb, would you recommend just dropping McNabb (obviously depending on where he ends up)?

[skip]

If we can swing a deal for Kolb, would you recommend just dropping McNabb (obviously depending on where he ends up)?

No way.

And being an owner of Kolb, Cassel and the 2.06 isn't nearly enough for me to deal him.

[JayT]

I wasn't talking about offering Cassel and 2.06 for Kolb.

If I were to trade Young for 2.06, then I'd have an empty spot in my 10 to keep...thus, would keep Cassel. If I don't trade Young, then I just drop Cassel. So is the extra draft pick worth the drop from Young to Cassel?

[Steelersfan]

I wasn't talking about offering Cassel and 2.06 for Kolb.

If I were to trade Young for 2.06, then I'd have an empty spot in my 10 to keep...thus, would keep Cassel. If I don't trade Young, then I just drop Cassel. So is the extra draft pick worth the drop from Young to Cassel?

So it would look like this if it was a trade...Young for the 2.06 and Cassel?

[JayT]

Yes, which side would you prefer? And if we keep Young, do you think we could get anything for Cassel in a trade?

[skip]

Yes, which side would you prefer? And if we keep Young, do you think we could get anything for Cassel in a trade?

Sorry, I read that other one as Kolb not as Young. And I wouldn't want Cassel plus the 2.06 for him either. I wouldn't part with much of anything for Cassel.

[Steelersfan]

Yes, which side would you prefer? And if we keep Young, do you think we could get anything for Cassel in a trade?

Considering you would still have McNabb and Sanchez I would probably rather have Cassel and the 2.06.

[skip]

Yes, which side would you prefer? And if we keep Young, do you think we could get anything for Cassel in a trade?

Considering you would still have McNabb and Sanchez I would probably rather have Cassel and the 2.06.

I'd deal Sanchez for that before I would Vince Young. But I know that most here probably wont agree. And I still wouldn't keep Cassel.

[JayT]

Skip,

Why do you like Young more than Sanchez? Both play in similar rush-dominant offenses. Sanchez has better weapons to throw to and was only a rook last year. I look for continued improvement from him.