Mike Evans, Amari Cooper, Sammy Watkins - Trade value?

[lukkynumber13]

I'm rebuilding an orphan team, 12T IDP, 53-man roster, PPR, non-salaried/contract (keep as long as you want)

I've accumulated 6 2017 1sts, and 4 2017 2nds

My only core players on offense at this post by are Carlos Hyde, Jordan Matthews, and Moncrief.

I want to trade for one of the 3 young stud WRs, but how would you rank those 3, and what would be a trade package that's fair?

[HughHoney]

I owned all 3 but dealt Evans this offseason. My personal ranking is:

Watkins
Cooper
Evans

Two of your 17 1sts and one of those players would be a reasonable first offer.

[Stabsinthe]

Two of your 17 1sts and one of those players would be a reasonable first offer.

Agreed. A few weeks ago, picked up Evans for 1.08, Moncrief, and a 2017 1st.

[knotts4372]

cooper, watkins, evans in order for me

[lukkynumber13]

Ok, so the Cooper owner won't deal him. I've made offers for

Evans: Matthews, Hyde, and 2017 1st
And Watkins: three 2017 1sts

I'm also thinking about making a play for Alshon, although the price would have to be really good since he isn't much good to me the next year or 2, and he ain't getting any younger

[Boxseed]

Ok, so the Cooper owner won't deal him. I've made offers for

Evans: Matthews, Hyde, and 2017 1st
And Watkins: three 2017 1sts

I'm also thinking about making a play for Alshon, although the price would have to be really good since he isn't much good to me the next year or 2, and he ain't getting any younger

I'd sit tight on those 2017 1st unless someone is coming at you and willing to pay... But cheaper guys keep spreading the wealth... Buy those guys before there value goes up like Watkins coop and them, if you can get players cheap I like dgb Floyd moncreif, ty is even going cheap these days etc Kevin white...

[BelichekYourSelf]

Ok, so the Cooper owner won't deal him. I've made offers for

Evans: Matthews, Hyde, and 2017 1st
And Watkins: three 2017 1sts

I own Watkins and Evans in both of my leagues. Those are fair offers... I wouldn't even think about it before rejecting them though. Fair offers won't get you those players at this point. You'll need to overpay which I don't think is in your best interest. Rebuilding you should be targeting undervalued players... Maybe check on the Keneen Allen owner..

[lukkynumber13]

Thanks guys! So the Alshon owner sent me a trade of Jeffery and 2 throw ins for:
2 2017 firsts (including mine which almost certainly will be top 3-4) and K. Mack (LB designation)

[Coogan Football]

Thanks guys! So the Alshon owner sent me a trade of Jeffery and 2 throw ins for:
2 2017 firsts (including mine which almost certainly will be top 3-4) and K. Mack (LB designation)

I would pass. I'm not a Jeffrey fan and Khalil Mack will probably be officially changed to DE before long and he will be worth a ton.

[lukkynumber13]

So the Mike Evans owner is finally ready to deal, but he wants "at least" 3 of my 2017 1sts. I'm still inclined to do that, but what are y'alls thoughts?

[BelichekYourSelf]

So the Mike Evans owner is finally ready to deal, but he wants "at least" 3 of my 2017 1sts. I'm still inclined to do that, but what are y'alls thoughts?

As much as I like that deal valuewise and I LOVE Evans, I would have to think long and hard about doing that with your team.. You have so many needs that giving up all those picks for one player could be a bad move long term.

[Coogan Football]

So the Mike Evans owner is finally ready to deal, but he wants "at least" 3 of my 2017 1sts. I'm still inclined to do that, but what are y'alls thoughts?

As much as I like that deal valuewise and I LOVE Evans, I would have to think long and hard about doing that with your team.. You have so many needs that giving up all those picks for one player could be a bad move long term.

I agree and Evans is not someone I'd feel safe enough doing that with

[Boxseed]

So the Mike Evans owner is finally ready to deal, but he wants "at least" 3 of my 2017 1sts. I'm still inclined to do that, but what are y'alls thoughts?

Hold tight once 2017 comes around people will be paying crazy prices that's how you rebuild you're team.

[hoos89]

I'd sit on those firsts for now (especially yours) unless you get an offer that just blows your socks off. I wouldn't be looking to deal multiple 1sts at even value or close to it in your position.

[KAT]

I owned all 3 but dealt Evans this offseason. My personal ranking is:

Watkins
Cooper
Evans

Two of your 17 1sts and one of those players would be a reasonable first offer.

So, Watkins foot and low volume passing offense, are having very little influence on your valuation of Watkins...

Thats interesting.... I've been offered Watkins for my C. Coleman/S. Shepard and I couldnt pull the trigger....