Jamal Charles vs.LeSean Mccoy

[footballworld2004]

Which player is better moving forward?

[footballworld2004]

I prefer McCoy because he is not recovering from ACL surgery and is a few years younger than Charles.

[footballworld2004]

Oh yeah excellent point. Thanks for the advice.

[footballworld2004]

If Charles is healthy I think he has the higher ceiling. He bounced back strong the year after his last ACL injury but he was a few years younger then. Plus I think Karlos Williams is a bigger threat to McCoy's workload than West and Ware are to Charles' workload.

[footballworld2004]

Thanks for your opinions. You guys know your stuff I'm glad I asked for some advice.

[footballworld2004]

I say McCoy is the better player going forward. He was hurt last year. He will bounce back this season. He's just as talented as Charles but he's healthy now and younger than Charles. Charles' ACL recovery is concerning.

[footballworld2004]

Wow! Becoming a member of this website was a great decision. The responses have been great. Thanks again guys. I really appreciate it.

[footballworld2004]

No Charles is way better . He's the guy to want.

[footballworld2004]

Charles is done, McCoy is the guy you want. McCoy has 3 good years left. Charles has 1 good year left at best.

[footballworld2004]

They're both done. Move on to more exciting younger players.

[footballworld2004]

I just don't know who is better. HELP ME! HELP ME!

[Shoreline Steamers]

I prefer McCoy because he is not recovering from ACL surgery and is a few years younger than Charles.

This is where I'm at. But either way, I'm looking at adding Karlos Williams if I went the McCoy route if possible/affordable. And I'd also add Spencer Ware behind Charles since I prefer him to Charcandrick West if I went with the KC backfield.

[DYNASTY BALLA$]

McCoy is great but Jamaal is the focal point of the KC offense when healthy.

Even at 29, I prefer Jamaal Charles over LeSean McCoy

Just my $.02

[jr00027]

I really enjoyed this post- people should totally do this instead of typing bump.

I own them both in my two serious leagues.

I'd take McCoy.

As an owner, Jamal Charles' value across my league is at an all time low. In order to move him, I'll need to wait till mid season and hope he's smashing it. He's on the verge of being on my roster until he croaks. Love the guy, but his value has never been so low.

McCoy still has some value and will produce for you while he's at it.

I don't think its too close.