Jeremy Maclin or Hakeem Nicks

[Salty Dawg]

Im looking for some insight as to what value Maclin or Nicks have in regards to this year's rookie mock.

Typical ppr 12 team dynasty. start 2 flex.

I also would like to consider if I go the other direction and perhaps let Sidney Rice go to get one of these two. What kind of rookie pick could I get with either one. I would consider 2011 rookie pick if I let Sidney.

Am I low balling with Sidney for Maclin and a 2011 2nd roudr or not. too much..not enough either way?
Thanks.

[Steelersfan]

Im looking for some insight as to what value Maclin or Nicks have in regards to this year's rookie mock.

Typical ppr 12 team dynasty. start 2 flex.

I also would like to consider if I go the other direction and perhaps let Sidney Rice go to get one of these two. What kind of rookie pick could I get with either one. I would consider 2011 rookie pick if I let Sidney.

Am I low balling with Sidney for Maclin and a 2011 2nd roudr or not. too much..not enough either way?
Thanks.

I would much rather have Rice.

[Salty Dawg]

Im looking for some insight as to what value Maclin or Nicks have in regards to this year's rookie mock.

Typical ppr 12 team dynasty. start 2 flex.

I also would like to consider if I go the other direction and perhaps let Sidney Rice go to get one of these two. What kind of rookie pick could I get with either one. I would consider 2011 rookie pick if I let Sidney.

Am I low balling with Sidney for Maclin and a 2011 2nd roudr or not. too much..not enough either way?
Thanks.

I would much rather have Rice.

Any thoughts on Maclin or Nicks as it relates to a rookie pick Mark? Got to both be 1st rounders..mid perhaps..?

[blacksheep]

Im looking for some insight as to what value Maclin or Nicks have in regards to this year's rookie mock.

Typical ppr 12 team dynasty. start 2 flex.

I also would like to consider if I go the other direction and perhaps let Sidney Rice go to get one of these two. What kind of rookie pick could I get with either one. I would consider 2011 rookie pick if I let Sidney.

Am I low balling with Sidney for Maclin and a 2011 2nd roudr or not. too much..not enough either way?
Thanks.

I would much rather have Rice.

x2

[Steelersfan]

Im looking for some insight as to what value Maclin or Nicks have in regards to this year's rookie mock.

Typical ppr 12 team dynasty. start 2 flex.

I also would like to consider if I go the other direction and perhaps let Sidney Rice go to get one of these two. What kind of rookie pick could I get with either one. I would consider 2011 rookie pick if I let Sidney.

Am I low balling with Sidney for Maclin and a 2011 2nd roudr or not. too much..not enough either way?
Thanks.

I would much rather have Rice.

Any thoughts on Maclin or Nicks as it relates to a rookie pick Mark? Got to both be 1st rounders..mid perhaps..?

I think you have it right, somewhere in the 5-8 range for me.

[hostile]

Im looking for some insight as to what value Maclin or Nicks have in regards to this year's rookie mock.

Typical ppr 12 team dynasty. start 2 flex.

I also would like to consider if I go the other direction and perhaps let Sidney Rice go to get one of these two. What kind of rookie pick could I get with either one. I would consider 2011 rookie pick if I let Sidney.

Am I low balling with Sidney for Maclin and a 2011 2nd roudr or not. too much..not enough either way?
Thanks.

I would much rather have Rice.

x2

x3

Easily.

[Manyx]

I see Nicks as a player worth the #4-#7 pick in rookie drafts. I think he is near the value of Dez and is more of a sure thing than the other rookie WR out there. I see Maclin with similar value, slightly lower than Nicks.

[yumbo]

I agree with everyone else. I would definitely keep Rice.

A first rd pick in the 6-10 range is a pretty fair price. But, I'd be asking myself what player am i targeting at that pick? If it's RB or QB that's fine, but if it's a WR, I'm not sure if there are any WR's in the draft (besides Bryant) that has any more upside than NIcks and Maclin. Plus, they already have a year of experience.

[jordanzs]

So for long term dynasty value, is Nicks better than Benn, Demaryus Thomas, or Tate? I have Calvin, Jennings, VJax, Crabtree, and Smith (NYG) on my team, and the 1.4 & 1.7 rookie picks. I'm needing a stud RB, so my 1.4 will likely be earmarked for one of them, but I was figuring to grab a WR at 1.7. Was also thinking of trying to trade that 1.7 pick for Nicks, maybe I could sweeten the deal & throw in Whitehurst (Nicks owner is a Seahawks fan) as I already have 3 QBs ahead of him. Hmmmmmm.

[MrUbuto]

I would much rather have Rice.

x2

x3

Easily.

yea and what happens with no favre???

[yumbo]

x2

x3

Easily.

yea and what happens with no favre???

Very good point...and no one will know anything about what Favre will do until training camp at the earliest.