am I overpaying for Julio?

[schiewerma21]

In team sig 2
Guy wants OBJ, Cooks, Vareen and a late first for Julio.

What do you think?

Thank you

[faulkfootball]

No thanks. I don't think OBJ is "sell high" material, as I think he has the ability to sustain his value. Which means, you could still do this deal in the off-season more than likely. I don't see a reason to make this deal. That, and it leaves you incredibly thin at RB.

[flexcapacitor]

It's a bit to much even for Julio. All of the players are worth a 1st round or 1st round +. You would have to take one piece out or get one back.

[GiantNinja]

Interestingly, I'm involved in negotiations for Graham for similar cost.

I offered OBJ + Cooks + a high second for Graham + a mid-first.

But you're sending Vereen as well, and not getting any pick in return.

That MIGHT be too much. But not by a lot.

I'd say that if you think it gives you a better shot at the title THIS year, pull the trigger. But if it's a move for the long term, wait. I think Cooks and OBJ are BOTH worth more this off-season than they are now.

[Falim]

Yea, OBJ and cooks are both looking like strong 1st rounders. I think you need to take either OBJ or cooks out of the deal.

[jeffster]

In team sig 2
Guy wants OBJ, Cooks, Vareen and a late first for Julio.

What do you think?

Thank you

Yeah, I love Julio but I don't know if I would pay that much for him. And I don't think you're deep enough at WR to do this regardless. If you could get Cooks or OBJ out, as someone else said, and include a smaller piece instead, then we could talk.