Upgrading from Addison

[Bay City Original]

Team 2 in my signature.

With some depth and relatively shallow starting requirements, I'm trying to trade some depth for an upgrade at WR. I've been dangling Addison, Diontae Johnson, and my 1.09. The Pittman and Aiyuk owners are interested in Addison and one of the other assets.

Using rookie draft pick for value, pick would you want with Aiyuk or Pittman in either of these deals?
Addison and Johnson for Aiyuk?

Addison and 1.09 for Pittman?

Are Aiyuk or Pittman enough of an upgrade to make the trade?

[StripesOfKC]

I actually traded Aiyuk for Addison and the 9th pick early in the offseason and when it seemed Aiyuk would get dealt I was really kicking myself

Even now I'm just eh with the deal. With a contending team that could really use a starter upgrade I'd go for it

[NathanielWegman]

I prefer Pittman because I’m a Colts fan…but with Downs being a year older and AD in the picture I think it’ll open it up for Pittman even more.

I’d try and hold the 1.09 in either deal and attach Johnson to Addison for either

[Bay City Original]

I prefer Pittman because I’m a Colts fan…but with Downs being a year older and AD in the picture I think it’ll open it up for Pittman even more.

I’d try and hold the 1.09 in either deal and attach Johnson to Addison for either

The owner, who was open to Addison and Johnson, asked me what else with Ayiuk... I'm trying to gauge what value to request without being too much. I was thinking the added parts should be minor so I was actually thinking about asking for Kendre Miller and/or Chase Brown. Too little? Too much?

[NathanielWegman]

Obviously you wanna get as much as possible, but not ask for to much and push him away…I would feel comfortable asking for Miller and doing this deal

[TheTroll]

Obviously you wanna get as much as possible, but not ask for to much and push him away…I would feel comfortable asking for Miller and doing this deal

Not a bad offer for sure