Caleb vs arich

[jponte3]

In a startup 12 team superflex , who would you prefer between Caleb and a rich?
Thanks for any feedback

[NathanielWegman]

I’m a Colts fan and I reluctantly voted for Caleb. AR scares me because he takes hits

[FantasyFreak]

A Rich has the higher ceiling. Caleb is "safer".

[TheTroll]

A Rich has the higher ceiling. Caleb is "safer".

[Anteaters]

I'm kind of surprised by the poll so far.
AR for me, but looking forward to seeing CW on the field.

[The.Big.Spank]

I think CW is safer and has the higher ceiling because he is the better passer with better weapons and can also run. He is more two dimensional than Richardson at this point.

[CGW]

Oddly enough they've played about the same amount in the NFL. As a Colts fan I really want to say AR is the answer, but I'm not sold after 4 injuries in 4 games, including a season ending injury.

Caleb is entering the NFL in one of the best spots I can remember. The Bears absolutely stacked the deck for him to succeed. Elite weapons, great defense, decent line. They will probably run some dreadfully stale offense and fumble the opportunity, but that's beside the point.

I'm taking Caleb. If I'm selling the 1.01 to get another QB I want it to be a more proven, reliable option.

[BigBawseRoss]

one of these guys has been known as a top passer for years and we anxiously awaited his arrival, the other is big strong and fast.

[kellysheroes]

A Rich has the higher ceiling. Caleb is "safer".

This

[FantasyFreak]

I think CW is safer and has the higher ceiling because he is the better passer with better weapons and can also run. He is more two dimensional than Richardson at this point.

I don't think Caleb can run in the NFL. A Rich was already a top 5 type QB in limited time last year. He's got league winning potential.

[TheTroll]

I think CW is safer and has the higher ceiling because he is the better passer with better weapons and can also run. He is more two dimensional than Richardson at this point.

I don't think Caleb can run in the NFL. A Rich was already a top 5 type QB in limited time last year. He's got league winning potential.

He can run but I actually think he won’t have to. Passing yards baby!

[FantasyFreak]

I think CW is safer and has the higher ceiling because he is the better passer with better weapons and can also run. He is more two dimensional than Richardson at this point.

I don't think Caleb can run in the NFL. A Rich was already a top 5 type QB in limited time last year. He's got league winning potential.

He can run but I actually think he won’t have to. Passing yards baby!

Sure, but unless you're in a league like this, the higher upside is A Rich.

https://www43.myfantasyleague.com/2024/home/54574#0

[TheTroll]

I don't think Caleb can run in the NFL. A Rich was already a top 5 type QB in limited time last year. He's got league winning potential.

He can run but I actually think he won’t have to. Passing yards baby!

Sure, but unless you're in a league like this, the higher upside is A Rich.

https://www43.myfantasyleague.com/2024/home/54574#0

I’d make a wager with you who would have the better FF season but I just learned it is against the gambling rules.

[FantasyFreak]

He can run but I actually think he won’t have to. Passing yards baby!

Sure, but unless you're in a league like this, the higher upside is A Rich.

https://www43.myfantasyleague.com/2024/home/54574#0

I’d make a wager with you who would have the better FF season but I just learned it is against the gambling rules.

BOOM! Shots fired! (Not in New Orleans)

[blemly]

I think CW is safer and has the higher ceiling because he is the better passer with better weapons and can also run. He is more two dimensional than Richardson at this point.

I don't think Caleb can run in the NFL. A Rich was already a top 5 type QB in limited time last year. He's got league winning potential.

He also can’t pass well. AR figures to be a better fantasy asset so long as his passing is adequate enough to keep him as a starter, but he possesses a higher bust risk even after having played 4 games imo.