2024 Bad Trade Offers

[BabyChark23]

12 team Superflex/3 RB league.

There's an extra 1.13 pick at the end of the first round.

Top 2 RB's were gone. Penix was the last QB left, and I was OTC at 2.02, for context. So pick 15.

Was offfered 3.01, 4.06 and 4.11 for 2.02 (Penix)

In a Vaccuum I don't think this is terrible value, but in this draft in particular, the 4th round is DRY

Top 8 NFL pick, starting QB in a superflex vs a day 3WR or RB, and a couple of late 4ths that will be UDFA/7th round type players?

I think it's a pretty bad offer, maybe not "terrible", but it's "bad" trade offers, not "terrible" trade offers.

Yeah, that one would classify as “terrible” to me.

[Shcritters]

12 team Superflex/3 RB league.

There's an extra 1.13 pick at the end of the first round.

Top 2 RB's were gone. Penix was the last QB left, and I was OTC at 2.02, for context. So pick 15.

Was offfered 3.01, 4.06 and 4.11 for 2.02 (Penix)

In a Vaccuum I don't think this is terrible value, but in this draft in particular, the 4th round is DRY

Top 8 NFL pick, starting QB in a superflex vs a day 3WR or RB, and a couple of late 4ths that will be UDFA/7th round type players?

I think it's a pretty bad offer, maybe not "terrible", but it's "bad" trade offers, not "terrible" trade offers.

Yeah, that one qualifies as a bad offer.

[thunderTung]

In a Vaccuum I don't think this is terrible value, but in this draft in particular, the 4th round is DRY

Top 8 NFL pick, starting QB in a superflex vs a day 3WR or RB, and a couple of late 4ths that will be UDFA/7th round type players?

I think it's a pretty bad offer, maybe not "terrible", but it's "bad" trade offers, not "terrible" trade offers.

Yeah, that one qualifies as a bad offer.

That's why I said in a vacuum. Let me be clear, I wouldn't accept this trade lol. Especially in this draft. I just don't think its terrible starting point to get a deal done

[Shoreline Steamers]

Top 8 NFL pick, starting QB in a superflex vs a day 3WR or RB, and a couple of late 4ths that will be UDFA/7th round type players?

I think it's a pretty bad offer, maybe not "terrible", but it's "bad" trade offers, not "terrible" trade offers.

Yeah, that one qualifies as a bad offer.

That's why I said in a vacuum. Let me be clear, I wouldn't accept this trade lol. Especially in this draft. I just don't think its terrible starting point to get a deal done

OTC during a draft come strong or don't come at all. Not only would I not have made that deal, I'd probably just go ahead and make my pick without even countering the offer. You want pick #15 and the best piece you're offering me is a drop of 11 spots? Easy pass.

[BradyT]

This just came in:

I get: JJ McCarthy(who the owner just drafted at 2.08)

I give: De'Von Achane, 2026 3rd


1QB league... + I have Mahomes

[TheTroll]

This just came in:

I get: JJ McCarthy(who the owner just drafted at 2.08)

I give: De'Von Achane, 2026 3rd


1QB league... + I have Mahomes

i nice ripe one!

[tstafford]

This just came in:

I get: JJ McCarthy(who the owner just drafted at 2.08)

I give: De'Von Achane, 2026 3rd


1QB league... + I have Mahomes

i nice ripe one!

This is the kind of trade offer we need to start of the week.

[Anteaters]

This just came in:

I get: JJ McCarthy(who the owner just drafted at 2.08)

I give: De'Von Achane, 2026 3rd


1QB league... + I have Mahomes

Quality post for this thread.

[Dynasty DeLorean]

This just came in:

I get: JJ McCarthy(who the owner just drafted at 2.08)

I give: De'Von Achane, 2026 3rd


1QB league... + I have Mahomes

Hmm, not sure if you are aware but JJM is better than Tom Brady

[Beer Makes Me Smile]

In a 1QB league I was offered this gem.

Get: Stroud
Give: 1.03, 1.08, and 1.11

[MacDaddy123]

In a 1QB league I was offered this gem.

Get: Stroud
Give: 1.03, 1.08, and 1.11

[MacDaddy123]

12 team SF TEP start 11, I got this beauty:

Give:
Kyler Murray
Jordan Love
Mark Andrews

Get:
1.01
David Montgomery

[wickerkat1212]

12 team SF TEP start 11, I got this beauty:

Give:
Kyler Murray
Jordan Love
Mark Andrews

Get:
1.01
David Montgomery

Gross. Maybe if it was Cousins and Rodgers sure, but not two young, talented QBs AND Andrews. Yikes.

[Shcritters]

We’re on fire to start the week - these are some LEGIT bad offers!

[thunderTung]

Sigh

Send:
ETN
Lamb

Receive:
1.06
‘25 1st
‘25 2nd
Khalil Herbert