K Murray + what = B. Robinson?

[Hottoddies]

I need some objective opinions. In a 16 team SF, Kyler Murray plus what equals Bijan Robinson?

[Anteaters]

IMO, in a 16tmSF
Bijan+? = Kyler

[Mtt33]

IMO, in a 16tmSF
Bijan+? = Kyler

Agreed 16 team Superflex I’d want a pretty big + on top of bijan for Kyler.

[TheTroll]

IMO, in a 16tmSF
Bijan+? = Kyler

Agreed 16 team Superflex I’d want a pretty big + on top of bijan for Kyler.

No doubt! 10 teamer is a different discussion.

[tstafford]

IMO, in a 16tmSF
Bijan+? = Kyler

Agreed 16 team Superflex I’d want a pretty big + on top of bijan for Kyler.

No doubt! 10 teamer is a different discussion.

x4

[Hottoddies]

I guess I should have added that the QB scoring is somewhat repressed in this league. Passing TDs are 4 pts. and interceptions are -3 pts. The top 3 last year were non QBs and 2 3rds of the top 24 were also non QBs. Does that change the equation at all?

[FantasyFreak]

What are the starting RB requirements? If it's 2, that sort of equals out the extra teams vs a 12 team league, as RB's are scarcer there, too.

[Hottoddies]

What are the starting RB requirements? If it's 2, that sort of equals out the extra teams vs a 12 team league, as RB's are scarcer there, too.

It's a must start 2 RBs league. In this setup I think an elite RB has a similar value as an elite QB.

[Anteaters]

I guess I should have added that the QB scoring is somewhat repressed in this league. Passing TDs are 4 pts. and interceptions are -3 pts. The top 3 last year were non QBs and 2 3rds of the top 24 were also non QBs. Does that change the equation at all?

Kyler has scored as many as 37 combined TDs (11 rushing) in a single season. Kyler has rushed for over 800yds in a season. Kyler is 26 years old. Kyler has arguably the best young TE in the league. Kyler is getting the best rookie WR in the draft later this month.

I don't see any way Bijan is worth more than Kyler in any 16tmSF league.

It's fine if you have a gut feeling or if Bijan is your guy and you want to go get him. When it comes to this hobby, we should all make the trades to acquire players that excite us.

But I don't think the numbers/stats/facts will support a Kyler:Bijan swap. And adding to Kyler makes this a very bad deal.

[Hottoddies]

I guess I should have added that the QB scoring is somewhat repressed in this league. Passing TDs are 4 pts. and interceptions are -3 pts. The top 3 last year were non QBs and 2 3rds of the top 24 were also non QBs. Does that change the equation at all?

Kyler has scored as many as 37 combined TDs (11 rushing) in a single season. Kyler has rushed for over 800yds in a season. Kyler is 26 years old. Kyler has arguably the best young TE in the league. Kyler is getting the best rookie WR in the draft later this month.

I don't see any way Bijan is worth more than Kyler in any 16tmSF league.

It's fine if you have a gut feeling or if Bijan is your guy and you want to go get him. When it comes to this hobby, we should all make the trades to acquire players that excite us.

But I don't think the numbers/stats/facts will support a Kyler:Bijan swap. And adding to Kyler makes this a very bad deal.

I accepted the offer:

I gave: Bijan Robinson + 2025 4th

I received: Kyler Murray + 2.13 + 2025 2nd

[tstafford]

I guess I should have added that the QB scoring is somewhat repressed in this league. Passing TDs are 4 pts. and interceptions are -3 pts. The top 3 last year were non QBs and 2 3rds of the top 24 were also non QBs. Does that change the equation at all?

Kyler has scored as many as 37 combined TDs (11 rushing) in a single season. Kyler has rushed for over 800yds in a season. Kyler is 26 years old. Kyler has arguably the best young TE in the league. Kyler is getting the best rookie WR in the draft later this month.

I don't see any way Bijan is worth more than Kyler in any 16tmSF league.

It's fine if you have a gut feeling or if Bijan is your guy and you want to go get him. When it comes to this hobby, we should all make the trades to acquire players that excite us.

But I don't think the numbers/stats/facts will support a Kyler:Bijan swap. And adding to Kyler makes this a very bad deal.

I accepted the offer:

I gave: Bijan Robinson + 2025 4th

I received: Kyler Murray + 2.13 + 2025 2nd

LOL. All this time I thought you were buying Bijan.

[Anteaters]

Kyler has scored as many as 37 combined TDs (11 rushing) in a single season. Kyler has rushed for over 800yds in a season. Kyler is 26 years old. Kyler has arguably the best young TE in the league. Kyler is getting the best rookie WR in the draft later this month.

I don't see any way Bijan is worth more than Kyler in any 16tmSF league.

It's fine if you have a gut feeling or if Bijan is your guy and you want to go get him. When it comes to this hobby, we should all make the trades to acquire players that excite us.

But I don't think the numbers/stats/facts will support a Kyler:Bijan swap. And adding to Kyler makes this a very bad deal.

I accepted the offer:

I gave: Bijan Robinson + 2025 4th

I received: Kyler Murray + 2.13 + 2025 2nd

LOL. All this time I thought you were buying Bijan.

Me too!

Hottoddies, glad this trade was the other way around! Hope it works out for you!

[MacDaddy123]

IMO, in a 16tmSF
Bijan+? = Kyler

Exactly!!

QB has the advantage in 16 team SF league, UNLESS, this is a trick SF league with no QB slot.

Many larger leagues (I've been in 16 and 20 team leagues) have no QB slot, only a SF slot.
In that case this would play like a 1 QB 16 team league, or an 8 team SF league.

[tstafford]

IMO, in a 16tmSF
Bijan+? = Kyler

Exactly!!

QB has the advantage in 16 team SF league, UNLESS, this is a trick SF league with no QB slot.

Many larger leagues (I've been in 16 and 20 team leagues) have no QB slot, only a SF slot.
In that case this would play like a 1 QB 16 team league, or an 8 team SF league.

Never seen that. Interesting twist. But it makes sense.

[FantasyFreak]

Wait a second......I think I know this league. LOL.

I think you did fine. Knowing the scoring, I think getting Kyler plus for Bijan was a good move for your team.