Barkley vs Cook

[hingle]

Hey All, just curious what the value difference is between Barkley and Cook. I have a rebuilding team that has Barkley on it and have been chatting with the Cook owner.

Just curious what the value difference is.

[TheTroll]

they are basically neck and neck for me. I would go personal preference.

[CGW]

Pretty similar players from a value standpoint. Barkley probably worth slightly more. In a rebuild, i'd probably be trying to shift Barkley for something other than a RB though.

[kellysheroes]

Barkley the better player but he always miss time
So one is higher risk, higher reward

[Black Adam]

Early '24 2nd (like the 2.03).


I'm passing on that though and betting on Barkley.

[The.Big.Spank]

Even to me too.

[BigBawseRoss]

i wouldnt come off barkley for cook, nobody will add anything that will make you actually wanna do it. cook can get yards but his td upside is super limited

[brewster]

Give me Barkley for contending... if needed to get the job done, add a current mid-late 2nd to get Cook if you prefer him. Or see where the season goes and trade later.... do you want to gamble or roll the dice now? It's your guts' call.

[repkllrs]

[quote=CGW post_id=2255722 time=1712923590 user_id= In a rebuild, i'd probably be trying to shift Barkley for something other than a RB though.
[/quote]
This

[Viking386]

I never understood the 1 for 1 at same position, unless you both just really like the other guys I guess. If you are truly trying to rebuild and wanting to tank then there is no need for you to even own a RB. Also if this is in regards to your team in signature, you have a solid squad. Why do you want to rebuild here?

[hingle]

Appreciate all the advice, this isn't for the team in my sig, this is for a team where we had a dispersal.

main pieces are:

Herbert, Young
Gibbs, Barkley, Edwards
Addison, Sutton, Dotson, Palmer, Mims, E. Moore, Samuel
Musgrave, Bellinger
1.02, 1.10, 1.11, 2.02

I was more so just looking to pick up a back that was younger and will be still in their prime in a year or two when my team is closer to competing. Not necessarily looking to go full tank on this one.