JJ for Waddle & Picks

[Badgersfan222]

Got an offer from a guy who wants to rebuild in 2025. I was also rebuilding but he wants draft capital. 12 team SF, PPR, & 1.75 TEP

He sends me: J. Jefferson, D. Carr, Monty, & J. Cook

I’d Give:

Waddle
3 firsts in 2025 (all late)
3 seconds 2025 (all late)

QB’s- J. Herbert, Cousins
RB- KW3, Achane, K. Miller, Alliger, A. Gibson
WR- Chase, Waddle, T. Higgins, Waddle, J. Reed, Addison, QJ,
TE- M. Andrews, Ferguson, Mayer, Fant

[tstafford]

Feels like an overpay to me. But I don't buy in to predicting where picks are going to land this far out. Especially three of them.

[Badgersfan222]

I agree. Feels like my team is on a path with draft capital.

Just the thought of JJ & Chase together

[lukkynumber13]

I think this is pretty darn even, although you'd better be a hopeful contender if you make this deal, since you're taking on some older assets

[Gator Sens]

Jefferson is the best piece but I think this comes down to if you think Montgomery and Cook are good assets over the next two or so years.

[Badgersfan222]

I’m not sure if this changes it, but the guy did agree to swap out Montgomery and change it to ETN

I feel like that changes it enough by getting three years younger with the #3RB

[tstafford]

I’m not sure if this changes it, but the guy did agree to swap out Montgomery and change it to ETN

I feel like that changes it enough by getting three years younger with the #3RB

Changes it for me. As much as I don't like paying for elite RBs (like ETN) nor do I like giving up a ton of draft capital, this deal is pretty nice. And I'm saying that with the POV that the picks are more random than necessarily late.

I'd take it. (And I try to flip ETN)

[killer_of_giants]

etienne is worth a 1st by himself, cook at a couple of seconds seems about right (or even all 3, if they're all late).

then you have waddle and two late 1sts for jefferson and you get a free carr. i'd say it's a pretty good deal.

[TheTroll]

I’m not sure if this changes it, but the guy did agree to swap out Montgomery and change it to ETN

I feel like that changes it enough by getting three years younger with the #3RB

Changes it for me. As much as I don't like paying for elite RBs (like ETN) nor do I like giving up a ton of draft capital, this deal is pretty nice. And I'm saying that with the POV that the picks are more random than necessarily late.

I'd take it. (And I try to flip ETN)

This

[The.Big.Spank]

I think thats a fair trade for JJ and I would take it.

[Dynasty DeLorean]

Etienne probably makes it a fair deal. Given the TEP aspect, even late 1sts are really valuable.

[abloom]

seems fine to me. though i'd look to flip carr almost immediately.

[tstafford]

seems fine to me. though i'd look to flip carr almost immediately.

In my experience (as a SF Carr manager) that isn't likely to work. He's probably worth more as a QB3 option than what you'll get in draft picks in return. But it's worth a try. And if the offer is a random 2nd, I'd say that's about the ceiling on value. Just depends on whether you'd prefer the random 2nd or a guy who's going to put un ~14 points in your SF slot on bye weeks. Does seem that NOS is fairly committed to him. But ~14 points kind of stinks.

[abloom]

seems fine to me. though i'd look to flip carr almost immediately.

In my experience (as a SF Carr manager) that isn't likely to work. He's probably worth more as a QB3 option than what you'll get in draft picks in return. But it's worth a try. And if the offer is a random 2nd, I'd say that's about the ceiling on value. Just depends on whether you'd prefer the random 2nd or a guy who's going to put un ~14 points in your SF slot on bye weeks. Does seem that NOS is fairly committed to him. But ~14 points kind of stinks.

I think a random second would be fine for carr.

[Tvols]

with ETN i thinks it ok deal, just depends on how u fee about your own build. I lean to take it..