Xavier McKinney or Jordan Battle

[Menace2010]

Which would you prefer? Team offered McKinney in a deal for Battle and Poyer.

Battle is promising and has performed well the last two weeks. Poyer is solid, but also aging. McKinney seems like a solid combination of the two, but obviously has contract concerns with this being his last year under contract...

I have depth at S, so this would also free up a roster spot currently being used on a DB (likely for whenever someone comes off IR, the waiver is thin)...

[lukkynumber13]

Always treat safeties as redraft.

That doesn’t necessarily make this a no-brainer either way, as both Battle and McKinney project to spend a lot of time soaking up snaps on bad teams down the stretch.

Since it IS dynasty tho, I think it’s fair to use future value as a tie-breaker. Keep battle.

But it’s a coin toss

[MacDaddy123]

I'd want Battle, as he looks like he is now ready to take over Vonn Bell's role as SS.
Bell was very successful in that Bengals defense for many years.